School counselors play a pivotal role in educational institutions, serving as essential advocates for students' academic success, social-emotional development, and college/career readiness. According to the American School Counselor Association, effective school counselors must demonstrate exceptional communication skills, emotional intelligence, and the ability to collaborate with diverse stakeholders while maintaining appropriate boundaries and confidentiality.

In today's complex educational landscape, school counselors manage increasingly diverse responsibilities – from implementing comprehensive counseling programs and conducting individual and group sessions to crisis intervention and educational planning. They serve as vital bridges between students, families, teachers, and administrators, requiring an adaptable and resilient approach to meeting evolving student needs. The most successful counselors balance data-driven practices with compassionate support, ensuring all students receive the guidance necessary to thrive both academically and personally.

When evaluating candidates for school counselor positions, behavioral interviews provide the most reliable insights into how candidates have handled real situations in the past. By asking questions focused on specific past experiences rather than hypothetical scenarios, interviewers can gather concrete evidence of a candidate's competencies, decision-making processes, and problem-solving abilities. To maximize effectiveness, follow each question with thoughtful probes that delve deeper into the situation, actions taken, and results achieved. This approach allows you to assess the candidate's true capabilities rather than their ability to provide idealized responses.

Before conducting interviews, consider reviewing a comprehensive interview guide to ensure you're evaluating all critical competencies required for successful school counselors. Additionally, developing a structured interview scorecard will help maintain consistency across candidates and reduce potential bias in the evaluation process.

Interview Questions

Tell me about a time when you had to work with a particularly challenging student who was resistant to counseling or support. How did you build rapport and make progress?

Areas to Cover:

• The specific challenge presented by the student
• Initial approach and why it was chosen
• How the candidate adapted their approach when facing resistance
• Specific techniques used to build trust and rapport
• How progress was measured and tracked
• Involvement of other stakeholders (teachers, parents, etc.)
• Long-term outcomes or lessons learned

Follow-Up Questions:

• What signals or behaviors indicated the student was resistant to support?
• How did you modify your counseling approach based on this student's specific needs?
• What was the turning point in your relationship with this student?
• How did you know when your approach was working?

Describe a situation where you had to balance the confidentiality of a student with the need to involve others for the student's well-being. How did you navigate this ethical dilemma?

Areas to Cover:

• The nature of the confidential information (without breaching actual confidentiality)
• The ethical considerations and potential risks involved
• Decision-making process used to determine appropriate action
• How the candidate communicated with the student about limits of confidentiality
• How the candidate involved others while maintaining trust with the student
• The outcome of the situation and impact on the student
• Reflection on whether the candidate would handle it differently in retrospect

Follow-Up Questions:

• What specific ethical guidelines or principles guided your decision-making?
• How did you explain your decision to the student?
• What steps did you take to maintain the student's trust while still involving necessary parties?
• How did this experience shape your approach to similar situations in the future?

Tell me about a time when you implemented a new counseling program or initiative at your school. What need did it address, and how did you measure its effectiveness?

Areas to Cover:

• The data or observations that identified the need
• The planning and development process
• How stakeholders were involved in planning and implementation
• Resources required and how they were secured
• Challenges encountered during implementation
• Metrics used to evaluate effectiveness
• Results achieved and lessons learned

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you get buy-in from administrators, teachers, or other stakeholders?
• What obstacles did you encounter, and how did you overcome them?
• How did you collect and analyze data to determine the program's impact?
• What would you change if you were to implement this program again?

Share an example of when you had to collaborate with teachers or administrators who had different perspectives on how to support a particular student. How did you navigate that situation?

Areas to Cover:

• The specific situation and differing perspectives
• How the candidate understood the various viewpoints
• Communication approaches used to find common ground
• How student needs remained central to the discussion
• Steps taken to build consensus
• The ultimate resolution and its impact on the student
• Lessons learned about effective collaboration

Follow-Up Questions:

• What were the main points of disagreement, and why do you think those differences existed?
• How did you ensure the student's perspective was considered in the discussion?
• What specific strategies did you use to help bridge the gap between differing viewpoints?
• How did this experience affect your approach to future collaborative situations?

Describe a situation where you used data to identify a trend or issue affecting students, and the steps you took to address it.

Areas to Cover:

• The type of data collected and analyzed
• How the data revealed the trend or issue
• The process used to validate findings
• How the candidate translated data into actionable insights
• Steps taken to develop an intervention or response
• How stakeholders were engaged in the solution
• Measurement of intervention effectiveness
• How the data informed ongoing improvements

Follow-Up Questions:

• What prompted you to look at this particular data in the first place?
• What challenges did you encounter in analyzing or interpreting the data?
• How did you present your findings to administrators or other stakeholders?
• What results did you see from your intervention, and how did you track them?

Tell me about a time when you had to support a student through a crisis situation. How did you respond in the moment and provide follow-up support?

Areas to Cover:

• The nature of the crisis (without sharing confidential details)
• Immediate assessment and response strategies
• Resources utilized or mobilized
• Communication with relevant stakeholders
• Short-term interventions implemented
• Long-term follow-up plan and implementation
• How boundaries were maintained while providing support
• Self-care strategies utilized by the counselor

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you determine the severity of the situation and necessary intervention level?
• What protocols or guidelines did you follow during the crisis?
• How did you coordinate with other professionals or resources?
• What systems did you put in place to monitor the student's progress after the immediate crisis?

Share an experience when you advocated for a student or group of students who were underserved or facing systemic barriers. What steps did you take and what was the outcome?

Areas to Cover:

• How the inequity or barrier was identified
• Research or data gathered to support the advocacy effort
• Key stakeholders engaged in the process
• Specific actions taken to advocate for change
• Resistance encountered and how it was addressed
• Results achieved for the students
• Long-term impact on policies or practices
• Lessons learned about effective advocacy

Follow-Up Questions:

• What motivated you to take action in this particular situation?
• How did you build support among colleagues or administrators?
• What obstacles did you face, and how did you overcome them?
• How did you involve the affected students in the advocacy process?

Describe a time when you had to adapt your counseling approach to meet the needs of a student from a cultural background different from your own.

Areas to Cover:

• The specific cultural considerations at play
• Steps taken to increase cultural understanding
• How biases or assumptions were recognized and addressed
• Modifications made to counseling approach
• Resources or support utilized to enhance cultural competence
• Outcome for the student and relationship
• Impact on future work with diverse populations

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you recognize that cultural factors were influencing the counseling relationship?
• What specific resources or people did you consult to enhance your understanding?
• How did you balance respecting cultural differences while still addressing the core counseling need?
• What did you learn that has informed your approach with other students?

Tell me about a time when you had to manage a high caseload or competing priorities. How did you ensure all students received the support they needed?

Areas to Cover:

• The specific demands and constraints faced
• System used to assess needs and prioritize
• Time management and organizational strategies
• How urgent vs. important needs were balanced
• Resources leveraged or delegated to
• Communication with stakeholders about capacity
• Self-care practices maintained during high-demand periods
• Reflection on effectiveness and areas for improvement

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you determine which students needed the most immediate attention?
• What systems or tools did you implement to stay organized?
• How did you communicate limits or boundaries with stakeholders?
• What would you do differently if faced with a similar situation in the future?

Share an example of how you've used technology or innovative approaches to enhance your school counseling program.

Areas to Cover:

• The specific need or challenge being addressed
• Research conducted on potential solutions
• Implementation process and stakeholder training
• How student privacy and data security were maintained
• Student and stakeholder response to the innovation
• Measurement of effectiveness and outcomes
• Adaptations made based on feedback
• Lessons learned about innovation in school counseling

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you identify this particular technology or approach as a potential solution?
• What resistance did you encounter when implementing this new approach?
• How did you ensure the technology was accessible to all students?
• What unexpected benefits or challenges emerged from this innovation?

Describe a situation where you had to provide counseling or guidance related to a sensitive or controversial topic. How did you approach this while respecting diverse viewpoints?

Areas to Cover:

• The nature of the sensitive topic
• Preparation and research conducted beforehand
• How personal biases were recognized and addressed
• Communication strategies used to create safe space
• How diverse perspectives were acknowledged and respected
• Resources or materials carefully selected
• Management of potential pushback from stakeholders
• Reflection on effectiveness and areas for improvement

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you prepare yourself to address this topic effectively?
• What considerations went into your planning process?
• How did you respond when faced with views that differed from your own?
• What feedback did you receive, and how did it shape future approaches?

Tell me about a time when you had to collaborate with external agencies or community resources to support a student or family. How did you coordinate these efforts?

Areas to Cover:

• The specific need that required external support
• How appropriate resources were identified
• Approach to making referrals or connections
• Management of confidentiality and information sharing
• Coordination of services between school and external providers
• Follow-up processes to ensure continuity of care
• Barriers encountered and how they were addressed
• Outcomes for the student or family

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you determine which external resources would be most appropriate?
• What steps did you take to maintain appropriate communication between all parties?
• What challenges did you face in coordinating between school and external services?
• How did you ensure the student/family was actively engaged in the process?

Share an experience when a counseling approach or intervention wasn't working as expected. How did you recognize this and what adjustments did you make?

Areas to Cover:

• The initial approach and rationale behind it
• Indicators that the approach wasn't effective
• How feedback was gathered from the student or others
• Process of reflecting and reassessing the situation
• Resources consulted or support sought
• Specific changes implemented
• How effectiveness of new approach was measured
• Lessons learned about flexibility and adaptation

Follow-Up Questions:

• What specific signs indicated your initial approach wasn't working?
• How did you balance giving an intervention enough time to work versus recognizing when change was needed?
• What resources or colleagues did you consult when developing a new approach?
• How did this experience influence your counseling practice moving forward?

Describe a time when you had to support a student dealing with grief or trauma. How did you provide appropriate support while maintaining professional boundaries?

Areas to Cover:

• Initial assessment of the student's needs
• Support strategies implemented in the school setting
• Collaboration with family members and other professionals
• Resources provided or referrals made
• How appropriate boundaries were maintained
• Follow-up and monitoring approach
• Self-care practices utilized
• Impact on personal and professional development

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you determine the appropriate level of support for this student?
• What specific resources or techniques did you find most effective?
• How did you communicate with teachers about supporting this student in the classroom?
• What indicators did you look for to assess the student's healing process?

Tell me about a successful college/career readiness initiative you implemented or contributed to. What made it effective for your student population?

Areas to Cover:

• Assessment of student needs and existing gaps
• Research or best practices that informed the initiative
• How the program was tailored to student demographics and needs
• Implementation strategy and timeline
• Resources secured and allocated
• Stakeholder involvement and buy-in
• Measurement tools and outcomes
• Sustainability plan and long-term impact

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you ensure the initiative was accessible and relevant to all student populations?
• What specific components had the greatest impact on student outcomes?
• How did you measure the initiative's success beyond immediate participation?
• What adjustments did you make based on student feedback or observed results?

Frequently Asked Questions

Why focus on behavioral questions rather than hypothetical scenarios when interviewing school counselor candidates?

Behavioral questions based on past experiences provide more reliable insights into how candidates actually perform in real situations. Past behavior is the best predictor of future performance. Hypothetical questions often elicit idealized answers that reflect what candidates think you want to hear rather than how they would actually respond. By asking about specific past experiences, you can evaluate the candidate's actual decision-making process, problem-solving skills, and ability to reflect on their practice.

How many behavioral questions should I include in a school counselor interview?

Quality matters more than quantity. It's better to ask 3-5 well-chosen behavioral questions with thorough follow-up than to rush through a dozen questions with superficial responses. Each behavioral question with proper follow-up typically takes 10-15 minutes to explore fully. Plan your interview time accordingly, allowing enough time to probe deeply into each response while covering the most critical competencies for the role.

How can I tell if a candidate is giving me prepared answers versus sharing authentic experiences?

Prepared answers often sound polished but lack specific details. Use follow-up questions to dig deeper into the specifics of the situation, asking for details about particular challenges, conversations, or decisions that wouldn't be part of a prepared script. Authentic responses typically include specific details, reflection on challenges or mistakes, and nuanced outcomes rather than perfect resolutions. The candidate's ability to provide context-specific details when prompted is a good indicator of authenticity.

Should I be concerned if a candidate needs time to think of an example?

Not at all. Thoughtful reflection before answering is often a positive sign that the candidate is searching for the most relevant and meaningful example rather than providing a rehearsed response. Give candidates adequate time to consider your question, and don't hesitate to prompt them with statements like, "Take your time to think of a specific example." This patience often yields more authentic and valuable responses.

How do I evaluate a candidate who has limited experience in a school setting but strong counseling skills from other environments?

Focus on transferable skills and underlying competencies rather than specific school experience. Use follow-up questions to help candidates draw parallels between their past experiences and school counseling scenarios. For example, ask how they would adapt approaches from their previous settings to meet school-specific needs. Also, assess their understanding of educational environments, their eagerness to learn school-specific protocols, and their ability to build relationships in educational contexts.

Interested in a full interview guide for a School Counselor role? Sign up for Yardstick and build it for free.