Essential Work Samples for Hiring a Product Design Director

The Product Design Director role is pivotal in shaping both product excellence and team culture. This leadership position requires a unique blend of creative vision, strategic thinking, and people management skills that can be challenging to assess through traditional interviews alone. While portfolios showcase past work, they often fail to reveal how candidates approach new challenges, collaborate with cross-functional teams, or lead design organizations.

Work samples provide a window into a candidate's real-world capabilities by simulating the actual challenges they'll face in the role. For a Product Design Director, these exercises should evaluate strategic thinking, leadership approach, collaboration skills, and design process expertise. The right work samples will reveal not just what candidates have done, but how they think, communicate, and lead.

Companies that implement thoughtful work samples in their hiring process for design leadership roles report higher success rates in identifying candidates who can truly drive design excellence while aligning with business objectives. These exercises also give candidates valuable insight into your organization's challenges and culture, creating a more transparent and engaging interview experience.

The following four work samples are specifically designed to evaluate the critical competencies required for a successful Product Design Director. Each exercise simulates real-world scenarios that design leaders face, providing both you and your candidates with a meaningful evaluation experience.

Activity #1: Design Strategy Alignment Exercise

This exercise evaluates a candidate's ability to develop a cohesive design strategy that aligns with business objectives—a fundamental responsibility for any Product Design Director. It reveals how candidates translate business goals into actionable design direction while demonstrating their strategic thinking and communication skills.

Directions for the Company:

• Prepare a brief (1-2 page) document outlining a fictional product challenge and business context. Include information about target users, business goals, market position, and current design challenges.
• Provide basic metrics about the product's performance and user feedback that highlight areas for improvement.
• Schedule a 60-minute session: 30 minutes for the candidate to present their strategy and 30 minutes for discussion and questions.
• Ensure key stakeholders from product management and executive leadership are present to evaluate cross-functional communication skills.
• Send materials to the candidate 48 hours before the scheduled session to allow adequate preparation time.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the provided materials and develop a high-level design strategy that addresses the business challenges while improving user experience.
• Prepare a 20-30 minute presentation that outlines:

1. Your assessment of the current design challenges
2. A proposed design strategy with clear objectives
3. How this strategy aligns with business goals
4. Key initiatives you would prioritize in the first 6 months
5. How you would measure success

• Be prepared to discuss your rationale and answer questions about your approach.
• Include examples of how you would communicate this strategy to different stakeholders (designers, product managers, executives).

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the presentation, provide specific feedback on one aspect of the strategy that was particularly strong and one area that could be strengthened.
• Ask the candidate to spend 10 minutes refining their approach to the area identified for improvement.
• Observe how receptive they are to feedback and how they incorporate it into their thinking—a critical skill for design leaders who must continuously adapt to new information.

Activity #2: Design Team Coaching Role Play

This exercise evaluates a candidate's leadership and mentorship abilities—essential qualities for a Product Design Director who will be responsible for developing design talent. It reveals how candidates provide feedback, guide designers, and foster a culture of growth and excellence.

Directions for the Company:

• Create a design review scenario with sample work from a fictional mid-level designer that contains both strengths and areas for improvement.
• Prepare a brief background on the fictional designer, including their experience level, strengths, areas for growth, and personality traits.
• Assign a team member to play the role of the designer receiving feedback.
• Allow 30 minutes for the exercise: 5 minutes for review of materials, 20 minutes for the feedback session, and 5 minutes for reflection.
• Provide the candidate with the design work and designer background 24 hours in advance.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the provided design work and designer background information.
• Prepare to conduct a 20-minute feedback session with the designer that:

1. Acknowledges the strengths of the work
2. Identifies areas for improvement
3. Provides actionable guidance for enhancing the design
4. Supports the designer's professional development

• Focus on balancing constructive criticism with positive reinforcement.
• Consider how to tailor your communication style to the designer's experience level and personality.
• Be prepared to answer questions the designer might have about your feedback.

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the role play, the interviewer will provide feedback on one aspect of your coaching approach that was effective and one area that could be improved.
• You'll have 5 minutes to reflect on this feedback and explain how you would adjust your approach in a follow-up session with the designer.
• This reflection demonstrates your ability to receive feedback and continuously improve your leadership approach—modeling the behavior you'd expect from your team.

Activity #3: Cross-Functional Collaboration Simulation

This exercise evaluates a candidate's ability to navigate complex stakeholder relationships and collaborate effectively with product and engineering teams—a critical skill for Product Design Directors who must champion design while balancing technical constraints and business priorities.

Directions for the Company:

• Create a scenario involving a design implementation challenge that requires negotiation between design vision, technical constraints, and business timelines.
• Prepare role descriptions for a Product Manager and Engineering Lead with specific concerns and priorities.
• Assign team members to play these roles, providing them with clear guidance on their positions and constraints.
• Schedule a 45-minute session: 10 minutes for the candidate to review materials, 25 minutes for the collaboration meeting, and 10 minutes for reflection.
• Provide the scenario overview to the candidate 24 hours in advance, but withhold specific stakeholder concerns until the exercise begins.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the provided scenario that outlines a design implementation challenge.
• During the exercise, you'll participate in a meeting with a Product Manager and Engineering Lead to resolve conflicts between design quality, technical feasibility, and delivery timelines.
• Your objectives are to:

1. Understand each stakeholder's concerns and constraints
2. Advocate effectively for design quality and user experience
3. Identify creative compromises that respect all perspectives
4. Build consensus around a path forward
5. Establish clear next steps and responsibilities

• Focus on demonstrating collaborative problem-solving while maintaining design integrity.
• Be prepared to make real-time decisions and adjustments as new information emerges during the discussion.

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the simulation, you'll receive feedback on one aspect of your collaboration approach that was effective and one area that could be strengthened.
• You'll have 10 minutes to reflect on how you might handle a follow-up meeting differently based on this feedback.
• This reflection helps assess your adaptability and continuous improvement mindset—essential qualities for design leaders working in dynamic environments.

Activity #4: User Research Planning and Synthesis

This exercise evaluates a candidate's expertise in user research methodologies and their ability to translate research insights into actionable design direction—a fundamental responsibility for Product Design Directors who must ensure user-centered design practices.

Directions for the Company:

• Prepare a brief describing a product challenge that requires deeper user understanding to solve effectively.
• Include information about the target audience, current product state, and business objectives.
• Provide any existing user data or feedback that might inform the research approach.
• Schedule a 60-minute session: 30 minutes for the candidate to present their research plan and 30 minutes for discussion.
• Send materials to the candidate 48 hours before the scheduled session.
• Optionally, include a small set of raw user feedback or interview transcripts for the candidate to synthesize.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the provided materials and develop a comprehensive user research plan that addresses the product challenge.
• Prepare a 20-30 minute presentation that outlines:

1. Your assessment of the current knowledge gaps
2. A proposed research methodology with rationale
3. Specific research questions you aim to answer
4. How you would recruit participants and conduct the research
5. Your approach to analyzing and synthesizing findings
6. How you would translate insights into actionable design direction

• If provided with raw user data, include a brief synthesis of key patterns and implications for design.
• Be prepared to discuss how you would scale research practices across a design organization and empower designers to incorporate user insights into their work.

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the presentation, you'll receive feedback on one strength of your research approach and one area that could be enhanced.
• You'll have 15 minutes to refine one aspect of your research plan based on this feedback.
• This demonstrates your ability to iterate on methodologies and incorporate new perspectives—essential for leading effective research initiatives that drive design decisions.

Frequently Asked Questions

• How long should we allow for these exercises in our interview process?

  Each exercise requires approximately 45-60 minutes to complete effectively. We recommend spreading them across different interview stages rather than attempting to conduct multiple exercises in a single day, which can be exhausting for candidates. The Design Strategy Alignment exercise works well as a final-stage assessment, while the Team Coaching Role Play can be effective earlier in the process.

• Should we use all four exercises for every candidate?

  Not necessarily. Select the exercises that best address your specific organizational needs and complement your existing interview process. For organizations prioritizing team development, the Design Team Coaching Role Play might be most valuable. For companies facing significant product challenges, the Design Strategy Alignment and User Research exercises might yield more relevant insights.

• How should we evaluate candidates' performance on these exercises?

  Create a structured evaluation rubric for each exercise that maps to the key competencies for your Product Design Director role. Have multiple stakeholders observe each exercise and score independently before discussing. Look beyond the specific solutions proposed to evaluate thought process, communication style, leadership approach, and adaptability.

• What if a candidate pushes back on completing these exercises?

  Be transparent about why these exercises are valuable for both parties. They provide candidates with insight into your organization's challenges while giving you a more holistic view of their capabilities. Consider offering compensation for extensive exercises, especially for senior roles. If a candidate still declines, this might indicate a mismatch in expectations or work style.

• How can we ensure these exercises don't disadvantage candidates from diverse backgrounds?

  Review exercise materials for potential bias in language or scenarios. Provide clear evaluation criteria focused on skills rather than cultural fit. Ensure diverse representation among evaluators. Give all candidates equal preparation time and resources. Consider accommodations for candidates with different needs or working styles.

• Can these exercises be conducted remotely?

  Yes, all four exercises can be adapted for remote interviews using video conferencing and collaborative tools. For the Design Team Coaching and Cross-Functional Collaboration exercises, ensure role players are comfortable with remote interaction. Provide clear technical instructions and offer a brief technology check before beginning the formal assessment.

The hiring process for a Product Design Director is a significant investment that will shape your design organization's future. These work samples provide a structured approach to evaluating the complex blend of skills required for this critical leadership role. By implementing these exercises, you'll gain deeper insights into candidates' capabilities while giving them a meaningful preview of the challenges they'll face in your organization.

For more resources to enhance your hiring process, explore Yardstick's suite of AI-powered tools, including our AI Job Description Generator, AI Interview Question Generator, and AI Interview Guide Generator. You can also find more information about hiring for Product Design Director roles at Yardstick's Product Design Director Job Description.

Ready to build a complete interview guide for your Product Design Director role? Sign up for a free Yardstick account today!