Essential Work Samples for Evaluating VP of Brand Marketing Candidates

The Vice President of Brand Marketing holds a pivotal position in any organization, serving as the architect of brand identity and the steward of market perception. This leadership role demands a unique blend of strategic vision, creative thinking, analytical prowess, and interpersonal finesse. Traditional interviews often fail to reveal whether candidates truly possess these multifaceted skills, making practical work samples an indispensable component of the hiring process.

Work samples provide a window into how candidates approach real-world challenges they'll face in the role. For a VP of Brand Marketing position, theoretical knowledge of marketing principles isn't enough—companies need leaders who can translate strategy into action, inspire teams, manage resources effectively, and adapt to rapidly changing market conditions. By observing candidates tackle authentic scenarios, hiring teams can assess not just what candidates know, but how they apply that knowledge.

The exercises outlined below are designed to evaluate the core competencies essential for success in this senior marketing role: strategic thinking, leadership capability, analytical acumen, communication skills, and cross-functional collaboration. Each activity simulates a different aspect of the VP role, allowing candidates to demonstrate their expertise in context rather than in abstraction.

Moreover, these work samples incorporate a feedback component, offering insight into a candidate's coachability—a critical trait for any executive who must continuously evolve with industry trends and organizational needs. The ability to receive constructive criticism and quickly implement improvements often distinguishes exceptional leaders from merely competent ones.

By implementing these carefully crafted exercises, your organization can move beyond resume credentials and interview impressions to make data-driven hiring decisions based on demonstrated performance. This approach not only identifies the most qualified candidates but also gives applicants a realistic preview of the role, ensuring alignment of expectations from the outset.

Activity #1: Brand Strategy Revitalization Exercise

This exercise evaluates a candidate's strategic thinking, analytical skills, and ability to develop comprehensive brand strategies aligned with business objectives. It reveals how candidates approach market research, competitive analysis, and brand positioning—core responsibilities for a VP of Brand Marketing.

Directions for the Company:

• Prepare a brief case study about a fictional company (or anonymized version of your own) facing brand challenges such as declining market relevance, changing consumer preferences, or increased competition.
• Include key business metrics, current brand positioning, target audience information, and competitive landscape details.
• Provide the case study materials to candidates 24-48 hours before the interview to allow for thoughtful preparation.
• Allocate 20 minutes for presentation and 10 minutes for questions and feedback.
• Assemble a small panel including the CMO, CEO or other relevant stakeholders who would typically interact with this role.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the provided case study and develop a comprehensive brand revitalization strategy.
• Prepare a 15-20 minute presentation outlining:

1. Analysis of current brand challenges and market position
2. Proposed brand positioning and messaging framework
3. Key initiatives to strengthen brand equity
4. Implementation roadmap with timeline and resource requirements
5. Success metrics and measurement approach

• Be prepared to explain your strategic thinking and defend your recommendations.
• Include visual aids (slides) to support your presentation.

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the presentation, interviewers will provide two pieces of feedback: one aspect of the strategy that was particularly strong, and one area that could be improved or further developed.
• The candidate will then have 5-7 minutes to address the improvement feedback by refining or expanding on that portion of their strategy.
• This tests the candidate's ability to receive feedback constructively and adapt their thinking—essential qualities for a senior marketing leader.

Activity #2: Marketing Campaign Leadership Role Play

This role play assesses the candidate's leadership abilities, creative vision, and communication skills when directing a marketing team. It simulates the collaborative process of developing campaign concepts and providing guidance to creative teams—a frequent responsibility for a VP of Brand Marketing.

Directions for the Company:

• Create a scenario where the candidate must lead a kickoff meeting for a new marketing campaign.
• Prepare a brief that includes campaign objectives, target audience information, budget parameters, and any brand guidelines.
• Assign 2-3 employees to play the roles of creative director, content strategist, and digital marketing manager.
• Brief these employees on how to respond naturally but also to raise specific challenges during the discussion.
• Provide the campaign brief to the candidate 24 hours before the exercise.
• Allocate 30 minutes for the role play.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the campaign brief and prepare to lead a kickoff meeting with the marketing team.
• During the 30-minute role play:

1. Articulate the campaign vision and objectives
2. Establish clear expectations and deliverables
3. Facilitate ideation while keeping the discussion focused
4. Address questions and concerns from team members
5. Delegate responsibilities and establish next steps

• Demonstrate your leadership style, ability to inspire creativity, and skill in guiding a team toward a cohesive vision.

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the role play, provide feedback on one aspect of the candidate's leadership approach that was effective and one area where their team management could be enhanced.
• Give the candidate 10 minutes to reflect on the feedback and describe how they would adjust their approach in a follow-up meeting with the team.
• This tests the candidate's self-awareness and ability to adapt their leadership style to team dynamics.

Activity #3: Marketing Budget Allocation and ROI Analysis

This exercise evaluates the candidate's analytical skills, financial acumen, and ability to make data-driven decisions about resource allocation—critical competencies for managing marketing budgets effectively and demonstrating ROI to executive leadership.

Directions for the Company:

• Create a realistic marketing budget scenario with historical performance data for various channels and initiatives.
• Include information about business objectives, target growth metrics, and any constraints.
• Prepare a spreadsheet template that candidates can use to develop their budget allocation.
• Provide these materials to candidates 24 hours before the interview.
• Allocate 30 minutes for presentation and discussion.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the provided marketing performance data and business objectives.
• Develop a proposed budget allocation across channels and initiatives for the upcoming year.
• Prepare a 15-minute presentation that includes:

1. Your recommended budget allocation with clear rationale
2. Expected ROI for each channel/initiative
3. Key performance indicators you would track
4. Contingency plans if certain channels underperform
5. Approach to optimizing spend throughout the year

• Be prepared to explain your analytical process and defend your recommendations.

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the presentation, interviewers will highlight one strength in the candidate's analytical approach and one area where their analysis could be more robust.
• The candidate will have 10 minutes to refine a specific portion of their budget allocation based on the feedback.
• This tests the candidate's financial reasoning and ability to adjust strategies based on new insights.

Activity #4: Brand Crisis Management Simulation

This simulation assesses the candidate's ability to handle pressure, make quick decisions, and protect brand reputation during a crisis—an increasingly important skill for marketing executives in today's fast-paced digital environment.

Directions for the Company:

• Develop a realistic brand crisis scenario relevant to your industry (e.g., product issue, social media backlash, negative press coverage).
• Create supporting materials such as mock social media posts, news articles, or internal emails about the situation.
• Prepare a timeline of how the crisis unfolds with new developments introduced during the exercise.
• Assemble a small crisis team including representatives from PR, legal, and executive leadership.
• Do not share details of the scenario with the candidate in advance.
• Allocate 45 minutes for the full simulation.

Directions for the Candidate:

• You will be presented with a brand crisis scenario that requires immediate attention.
• During this 45-minute simulation:

1. Assess the situation and its potential impact on brand reputation
2. Develop a crisis communication strategy
3. Draft key messages for different stakeholders (customers, employees, media)
4. Make recommendations about immediate actions to mitigate damage
5. Collaborate with the crisis team to implement your strategy

• New developments will be introduced during the exercise, requiring you to adapt your approach.
• Demonstrate your ability to remain calm under pressure, think strategically, and protect brand integrity.

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the simulation, provide feedback on one effective decision the candidate made and one aspect of their crisis response that could be improved.
• Give the candidate 10 minutes to revise their communication strategy or key messages based on the feedback.
• This tests the candidate's adaptability and ability to refine their approach in high-pressure situations.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much time should we allocate for these work samples in our interview process?

Each exercise requires approximately 30-45 minutes, plus preparation time. We recommend spreading these across different interview stages rather than conducting all four in a single day. For senior roles like VP of Brand Marketing, candidates expect a thorough process and will appreciate the opportunity to demonstrate their skills in different contexts.

Should we use our actual company data for these exercises?

While using real data creates authenticity, we recommend creating fictionalized versions of your data or anonymized case studies to protect confidential information. The scenarios should be realistic and relevant to your industry but not reveal proprietary information or future plans.

What if a candidate pushes back on completing these exercises?

For executive-level positions, candidates may have concerns about time commitment or intellectual property. Be transparent about how their work will be used and consider offering compensation for extensive exercises. Remember that high-quality candidates often have multiple opportunities, so ensure your process respects their time while still providing meaningful assessment.

How should we weight these exercises compared to traditional interviews?

These work samples should complement rather than replace traditional interviews. We recommend a balanced approach where work samples account for approximately 40-50% of your evaluation, with behavioral interviews, reference checks, and cultural fit assessments making up the remainder.

Can we adapt these exercises for remote hiring processes?

Absolutely. All these exercises can be conducted virtually using video conferencing platforms. For the role plays and simulations, ensure all participants have clear instructions and stable technology connections. Consider providing slightly more preparation time for remote candidates to account for potential technology challenges.

How do we ensure consistency in evaluating different candidates?

Develop a standardized rubric for each exercise that outlines specific criteria aligned with the competencies you're assessing. Have the same evaluation panel review all candidates whenever possible, and conduct calibration discussions to ensure evaluators are applying criteria consistently.

The VP of Brand Marketing role requires a unique combination of strategic vision, creative leadership, and analytical rigor. By incorporating these work samples into your hiring process, you'll gain invaluable insights into how candidates actually perform in scenarios relevant to the position. This approach not only helps identify the most qualified candidates but also demonstrates your company's commitment to excellence in hiring practices.

Ready to elevate your entire hiring process? Yardstick offers comprehensive tools to help you design and execute exceptional candidate interviews. From creating customized job descriptions with our AI Job Description Generator to developing targeted interview questions with our AI Interview Question Generator and building complete interview guides with our AI Interview Guide Generator, we provide everything you need to make informed hiring decisions. Check out our example VP of Brand Marketing job description at https://yardstick.team/job-description/vp-of-brand-marketing for more insights into this critical role.

Ready to build a complete interview guide for your VP of Brand Marketing role? Sign up for a free Yardstick account today!