Essential Work Sample Exercises to Evaluate AI Customer Service Automation Skills

AI-driven customer service automation represents one of the most transformative applications of artificial intelligence in business today. Companies implementing these solutions can dramatically improve customer satisfaction while reducing operational costs. However, finding candidates with the right blend of AI expertise, customer service understanding, and process automation skills presents a significant challenge for hiring managers.

Evaluating candidates for AI customer service automation roles requires more than reviewing resumes and conducting standard interviews. The complexity of these positions demands practical assessment of how candidates approach real-world challenges. Work samples provide invaluable insights into a candidate's problem-solving methodology, technical capabilities, and understanding of customer service dynamics.

The most effective candidates in this field demonstrate not only technical proficiency with AI tools and frameworks but also a deep understanding of customer service operations and the human elements of service interactions. They can identify which processes are suitable for automation, design solutions that enhance rather than detract from customer experience, and implement systems that integrate seamlessly with existing workflows.

The following work sample exercises are designed to evaluate candidates across multiple dimensions of AI customer service automation expertise. Each activity simulates realistic scenarios that professionals in this field encounter regularly. By observing how candidates approach these challenges, hiring managers can make more informed decisions about which individuals possess the right combination of skills, knowledge, and problem-solving abilities to drive successful AI implementation in customer service environments.

Activity #1: Customer Service Process Analysis and Automation Opportunity Mapping

This exercise evaluates a candidate's ability to analyze existing customer service processes, identify automation opportunities, and prioritize implementation based on business impact. This skill is fundamental as it represents the starting point of any successful AI automation initiative—understanding where and how AI can add the most value to customer service operations.

Directions for the Company:

  • Provide the candidate with documentation of a fictional (or anonymized real) customer service process flow, including volume metrics, average handling times, and common customer issues.
  • Include sample customer service transcripts or recordings that represent typical interactions.
  • Allow 60-90 minutes for this exercise.
  • Prepare a meeting room with whiteboard or digital collaboration tools for the candidate's presentation.

Directions for the Candidate:

  • Review the provided customer service process documentation and interaction samples.
  • Identify 3-5 specific opportunities for AI automation within the process.
  • For each opportunity:
  • Describe what type of AI solution would be appropriate (chatbot, sentiment analysis, automatic categorization, etc.)
  • Estimate the potential impact on metrics like handling time, first contact resolution, or customer satisfaction
  • Outline potential implementation challenges
  • Create a prioritization matrix for these opportunities based on estimated impact vs. implementation difficulty.
  • Prepare a 10-minute presentation of your findings and recommendations.

Feedback Mechanism:

  • After the presentation, provide feedback on one aspect the candidate analyzed particularly well and one area where their analysis could be improved or expanded.
  • Ask the candidate to spend 5-10 minutes revising their top automation opportunity recommendation based on the feedback, focusing on addressing the improvement area identified.

Activity #2: AI Chatbot Design for Customer Support

This exercise tests the candidate's ability to design an AI solution for a specific customer service challenge. It evaluates their understanding of conversational AI capabilities, limitations, and implementation considerations. This skill is crucial for translating business requirements into effective technical solutions that enhance customer experience.

Directions for the Company:

  • Prepare a brief on a specific customer support function (e.g., order tracking, returns processing, technical troubleshooting for a specific product).
  • Include sample customer queries and current response protocols.
  • Provide information about existing systems that would need to integrate with the chatbot.
  • Allow 2 hours for this exercise.

Directions for the Candidate:

  • Design a conversational flow for an AI chatbot that would handle the specified customer support function.
  • Create a diagram showing the conversation paths, decision points, and escalation criteria.
  • Specify what data the chatbot would need to access to resolve customer issues.
  • Identify which customer intents the chatbot should recognize and how it should respond to each.
  • Outline how the chatbot would handle exceptions, ambiguities, or situations beyond its capabilities.
  • Describe how you would measure the chatbot's effectiveness after implementation.
  • Prepare a document or presentation explaining your design decisions.

Feedback Mechanism:

  • Provide feedback on the strengths of the candidate's design and one area where the conversational flow could be improved for better customer experience.
  • Ask the candidate to revise the specific conversation path identified for improvement, explaining their changes and the reasoning behind them.

Activity #3: Customer Service AI Implementation Planning

This exercise assesses the candidate's ability to plan the technical implementation of an AI customer service solution. It evaluates their understanding of AI development workflows, integration requirements, and project management skills. This competency is essential for translating conceptual designs into actionable implementation plans.

Directions for the Company:

  • Provide a scenario describing a company's customer service environment, including current systems, team structure, and business objectives.
  • Include technical specifications of existing systems that would need to integrate with the new AI solution.
  • Specify constraints such as timeline, budget, or technical limitations.
  • Allow 2-3 hours for this exercise.

Directions for the Candidate:

  • Develop a detailed implementation plan for an AI-powered customer service solution that meets the specified business objectives.
  • Your plan should include:
  • Technical architecture diagram showing how the AI solution integrates with existing systems
  • Data requirements and sources
  • Development phases and timeline
  • Required resources (technical, human, data)
  • Testing methodology
  • Deployment strategy
  • Training plan for customer service staff
  • Risk assessment and mitigation strategies
  • Prepare a presentation of your implementation plan suitable for both technical and business stakeholders.

Feedback Mechanism:

  • Provide feedback on the strengths of the implementation plan and one area that could benefit from more detailed planning or risk mitigation.
  • Ask the candidate to spend 15 minutes expanding on the identified area, providing more detailed planning steps or risk mitigation strategies.

Activity #4: AI Customer Service Solution Prototype Development

This exercise evaluates the candidate's hands-on technical skills in developing AI solutions for customer service. It tests their ability to translate concepts into working prototypes and their proficiency with relevant AI tools and frameworks. This practical implementation skill is critical for candidates who will be directly involved in solution development.

Directions for the Company:

  • Prepare a simplified customer service dataset (e.g., categorized customer queries, sample conversations, or support tickets).
  • Specify a clear objective for the prototype (e.g., automatically categorize customer inquiries, detect customer sentiment, or generate response recommendations).
  • Provide access to necessary development tools or allow candidates to use their preferred environment.
  • Allow 3-4 hours for this exercise, or make it a take-home assignment with a 24-hour turnaround.

Directions for the Candidate:

  • Using the provided dataset, develop a working prototype of an AI component that addresses the specified objective.
  • Your solution should include:
  • Data preprocessing steps
  • Model selection and training approach
  • Implementation code (can be notebook-based)
  • Evaluation of the model's performance
  • Documentation explaining your approach and decisions
  • Suggestions for how the prototype could be improved with additional time or resources
  • Be prepared to demonstrate your prototype and explain your technical choices.

Feedback Mechanism:

  • Provide feedback on the strengths of the prototype and one area where the technical implementation could be improved.
  • Ask the candidate to explain how they would address the improvement area if they had additional time, including specific technical approaches they would take.

Frequently Asked Questions

How should we adapt these exercises for candidates with different experience levels?

For junior candidates, consider simplifying the scope of each exercise and providing more structured guidance. For senior candidates, increase complexity by adding constraints, scale considerations, or integration challenges. The core activities remain valuable across levels, but expectations for depth and breadth should align with experience.

What if our company doesn't have sample customer service data to provide?

You can create simplified fictional data that represents typical customer interactions in your industry. Alternatively, there are public datasets of customer service interactions available online that can be adapted for these exercises. The key is ensuring the data reflects realistic scenarios relevant to your business context.

How should we evaluate candidates who use different AI approaches than we currently use?

Focus on the candidate's reasoning and problem-solving approach rather than specific technologies. A strong candidate should be able to explain why they chose particular methods and demonstrate awareness of alternatives. Different approaches may offer valuable new perspectives for your team.

Should we expect candidates to complete all aspects of these exercises perfectly?

No. These exercises are designed to be challenging and comprehensive. Look for candidates who demonstrate strong problem-solving approaches, ask clarifying questions when needed, and show awareness of their solutions' limitations. The feedback portions of each exercise provide valuable insights into how candidates respond to critique and iterate on their work.

How can we make these exercises inclusive for remote candidates?

All these exercises can be adapted for remote completion using video conferencing, collaborative documents, and screen sharing. For the prototype development exercise, consider using cloud-based development environments or allowing candidates to use their own tools and share results. Ensure clear communication about expectations and available resources.

What if a candidate doesn't have experience with the specific type of AI solution we're evaluating?

Focus on transferable skills and learning ability. A candidate with strong fundamentals in AI and customer service can often quickly adapt to new application areas. Consider providing some background materials or resources to help candidates bridge knowledge gaps before the exercise.

AI for customer service process automation represents a rapidly evolving field where technical expertise must be balanced with customer experience sensitivity and business acumen. The right candidates will demonstrate not just technical proficiency but also thoughtful approaches to implementing AI in ways that genuinely enhance customer service operations.

By incorporating these work sample exercises into your hiring process, you'll gain deeper insights into candidates' capabilities than traditional interviews alone can provide. These practical evaluations reveal how candidates approach real-world challenges and help ensure you select team members who can successfully drive your AI customer service automation initiatives forward.

For more resources to optimize your hiring process, explore Yardstick's comprehensive tools for creating AI-powered job descriptions, generating effective interview questions, and developing complete interview guides.

Build a complete interview guide for AI customer service automation roles by signing up for a free Yardstick account here

Generate Custom Interview Questions

With our free AI Interview Questions Generator, you can create interview questions specifically tailored to a job description or key trait.
Raise the talent bar.
Learn the strategies and best practices on how to hire and retain the best people.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Raise the talent bar.
Learn the strategies and best practices on how to hire and retain the best people.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.