Essential Work Sample Exercises for Hiring Top-Performing Recruiters

Recruiting is a multifaceted role that requires a unique blend of sales, marketing, project management, and people skills. The best recruiters combine strategic thinking with tactical execution, building relationships while managing complex processes. When hiring for this critical position, traditional interviews alone often fail to reveal a candidate's true capabilities.

Work samples provide a window into how candidates will actually perform on the job. For recruiting roles specifically, these exercises allow you to observe candidates' sourcing creativity, communication style, assessment abilities, and process management skills in action. Rather than relying on how candidates say they would handle situations, you can directly observe their approach to real recruiting challenges.

The quality of your recruiting team directly impacts every other department in your organization. A great recruiter doesn't just fill positions—they elevate your entire talent acquisition function, improve candidate experience, and help build high-performing teams. By implementing structured work samples in your hiring process, you can identify recruiters who will deliver exceptional results.

The following four exercises are designed to evaluate the core competencies required for recruiting excellence. Each activity simulates a real-world scenario recruiters face daily, providing clear insights into which candidates possess both the technical skills and behavioral traits needed to succeed in this dynamic role.

Activity #1: Candidate Sourcing Strategy

This exercise evaluates a recruiter's ability to develop creative sourcing strategies, a fundamental skill for proactively finding qualified candidates in competitive talent markets. Great recruiters don't just post jobs and wait—they strategically identify and engage passive candidates through multiple channels.

Directions for the Company:

• Provide the candidate with a real or fictional job description for a hard-to-fill role in your organization.
• Include information about the role's requirements, team structure, and why previous sourcing efforts have been challenging.
• Allow the candidate 30-45 minutes to prepare their sourcing strategy.
• Schedule a 20-minute presentation followed by 10 minutes of questions.
• Assign 2-3 team members to evaluate the presentation, including at least one senior recruiter or talent acquisition leader.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the job description and develop a comprehensive sourcing strategy for finding qualified candidates.
• Outline specific channels, tools, and techniques you would use to identify potential candidates.
• Create sample outreach messages for different platforms (LinkedIn, email, etc.).
• Prepare to explain how you would measure the effectiveness of your sourcing efforts.
• Be ready to present your strategy in a clear, organized manner and answer questions about your approach.

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the presentation, provide one specific aspect of the sourcing strategy that was particularly strong or creative.
• Then offer one area for improvement, such as additional channels to consider or ways to refine outreach messaging.
• Give the candidate 5 minutes to verbally explain how they would incorporate the feedback and adjust their strategy accordingly.

Activity #2: Candidate Screening Simulation

This exercise assesses a recruiter's ability to effectively screen candidates through thoughtful questioning and active listening. The initial screening conversation is crucial for identifying qualified candidates while providing an excellent candidate experience that reflects positively on your company.

Directions for the Company:

• Select an employee or team member to play the role of a candidate applying for a position at your company.
• Provide the "candidate" with a detailed persona, including background, experience, and motivations.
• Give the recruiter candidate a job description and basic resume for the "candidate" 15 minutes before the exercise.
• Allow 20-25 minutes for the screening call simulation.
• Observe how the recruiter structures the conversation, asks follow-up questions, and handles potential red flags.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the job description and resume provided.
• Conduct a professional screening call as you would with a real candidate.
• Cover essential areas including experience verification, skills assessment, motivation, compensation expectations, and next steps.
• Take brief notes during the conversation to reference later.
• After the call, prepare a 2-3 minute verbal assessment of the candidate's fit for the role, highlighting strengths and potential concerns.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide feedback on one aspect of the screening that was particularly effective (e.g., insightful questioning, active listening).
• Offer one specific area for improvement (e.g., missed opportunity for follow-up, insufficient exploration of a potential concern).
• Ask the candidate to demonstrate how they would handle that specific area differently if they could redo part of the conversation.

Activity #3: Candidate Assessment and Hiring Manager Communication

This exercise evaluates a recruiter's ability to objectively assess candidates and effectively communicate insights to hiring managers. Great recruiters serve as strategic advisors, not just resume forwarders, helping managers make informed hiring decisions.

Directions for the Company:

• Provide the candidate with 3-4 fictional candidate profiles (resumes and brief interview notes) for a specific open position.
• Include the job description and a list of key requirements from the hiring manager.
• Allow 30 minutes for the candidate to review materials and prepare their assessment.
• Have someone play the role of the hiring manager for a 15-minute debrief conversation.
• The "hiring manager" should ask challenging questions about the candidates and push back on some recommendations.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review all candidate materials and the job requirements carefully.
• Evaluate each candidate against the key requirements, noting strengths and potential gaps.
• Prepare a structured assessment of each candidate with a clear recommendation on who to advance and why.
• Be prepared to discuss your reasoning with the hiring manager, focusing on objective evaluation criteria.
• Demonstrate how you would handle potential disagreement with the hiring manager while maintaining a collaborative approach.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide feedback on one aspect of the candidate's assessment or communication that was particularly strong.
• Offer one specific area for improvement in either their evaluation process or communication approach.
• Ask the candidate to revise their recommendation or re-explain their reasoning for one specific candidate, incorporating the feedback provided.

Activity #4: Recruiting Process Improvement

This exercise assesses a recruiter's ability to analyze and improve recruiting processes, demonstrating strategic thinking and problem-solving skills. Top recruiters continuously optimize workflows to improve efficiency, candidate experience, and hiring outcomes.

Directions for the Company:

• Provide a description of a fictional (or anonymized real) recruiting process with several inefficiencies or pain points.
• Include metrics like time-to-fill, candidate drop-off rates, and hiring manager satisfaction scores.
• Optionally, include a candidate journey map showing the current process flow.
• Allow 45-60 minutes for the candidate to analyze the information and prepare recommendations.
• Schedule a 20-minute presentation followed by 10 minutes of questions.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the recruiting process information provided.
• Identify 3-5 key areas for improvement, focusing on those that would have the greatest impact.
• Develop specific, actionable recommendations for each area.
• Create a simple implementation plan with prioritized steps and expected outcomes.
• Be prepared to explain how you would measure success for each improvement.
• Present your analysis and recommendations clearly and concisely.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Highlight one particularly insightful observation or recommendation from the candidate's presentation.
• Provide one area where their analysis could be strengthened or where they may have missed an important consideration.
• Ask the candidate to spend 5 minutes expanding on how they would address this additional consideration or strengthen their analysis in the area mentioned.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long should the entire work sample process take?

The complete set of exercises would require approximately 3-4 hours of a candidate's time, plus preparation. We recommend selecting 1-2 exercises most relevant to your specific needs rather than conducting all four. These can be integrated into different stages of your interview process.

Should these exercises be conducted in-person or virtually?

These exercises can be effective in either format. Virtual assessments offer flexibility and convenience, while in-person exercises provide additional insights into how candidates interact in your work environment. Choose the format that best aligns with your overall interview process.

How should we evaluate candidates who have experience in different industries?

Focus on the fundamental recruiting skills demonstrated rather than industry-specific knowledge. Great recruiters can adapt their approach across industries. Look for candidates who ask thoughtful questions about your industry context and demonstrate learning agility.

What if a candidate performs well in interviews but struggles with the work sample?

This discrepancy is precisely why work samples are valuable. They reveal practical skills that may not emerge in traditional interviews. Consider the specific areas where the candidate struggled and whether those skills are teachable or essential for day-one performance in your environment.

How should we weight these exercises compared to other interview components?

Work samples should be a significant factor in your decision-making process, as they demonstrate actual job performance. We recommend they account for approximately 40-50% of your overall evaluation, with behavioral interviews, reference checks, and other assessments making up the remainder.

Can these exercises be modified for different seniority levels?

Absolutely. For junior recruiters, you might focus more on fundamental skills like screening and sourcing. For senior roles, emphasize the strategic components like process improvement and hiring manager partnerships. Adjust the complexity and scope of each exercise based on the seniority of the position.

The quality of your recruiting function directly impacts every hire your organization makes. By incorporating these work samples into your interview process, you'll be able to identify recruiters who can truly elevate your talent acquisition efforts. These exercises go beyond theoretical knowledge to reveal how candidates will actually perform in the critical situations they'll face daily.

For more resources to optimize your hiring process, explore Yardstick's comprehensive tools for creating AI-powered job descriptions, generating effective interview questions, and developing complete interview guides.

Ready to build a complete interview guide for recruiting roles? Sign up for a free Yardstick account today