Essential Work Sample Exercises for Hiring Top Compensation Analysts

Compensation Analysts serve as the architects of an organization's pay strategy, wielding significant influence over talent attraction, retention, and overall business performance. Their expertise in data analysis, market research, and compensation structure development directly impacts an organization's ability to remain competitive in the talent marketplace while maintaining internal equity and controlling costs.

When hiring for this critical role, traditional interviews alone often fail to reveal a candidate's true capabilities. While a candidate may articulate compensation principles effectively during an interview, their ability to apply these concepts in practice remains untested. This is where well-designed work samples become invaluable.

Work samples for Compensation Analysts should evaluate not only technical proficiency with compensation data and tools but also the candidate's judgment, attention to detail, and communication skills. The best compensation professionals combine analytical rigor with strategic thinking and the ability to translate complex data into actionable insights for stakeholders.

The following exercises are designed to simulate real-world compensation challenges, providing a window into how candidates approach the core responsibilities of a Compensation Analyst. By incorporating these activities into your hiring process, you'll gain deeper insights into each candidate's capabilities and identify those who will excel in maintaining competitive, equitable, and compliant compensation practices for your organization.

Activity #1: Market Analysis and Salary Range Development

This exercise evaluates a candidate's ability to analyze compensation market data, interpret trends, and develop appropriate salary ranges. This skill is fundamental to ensuring your organization remains competitive in the talent market while maintaining internal equity and budget discipline.

Directions for the Company:

• Prepare a dataset containing anonymized market salary data for 5-7 positions within a job family (e.g., marketing, engineering, or sales roles).
• Include data points such as job titles, years of experience, company size, industry, location, and corresponding salary information.
• Provide basic information about your company's compensation philosophy (e.g., target percentile in the market, geographic considerations, etc.).
• Allow candidates 45-60 minutes to complete this exercise.
• Ensure the dataset has some inconsistencies or outliers that require critical thinking to address.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the provided market data and company compensation philosophy.
• Clean and organize the data, addressing any outliers or inconsistencies.
• Develop appropriate salary ranges for each position, including minimum, midpoint, and maximum values.
• Create a brief (1-2 page) recommendation document explaining:
• Your methodology for developing the ranges
• Key market insights that influenced your decisions
• Recommendations for implementing these ranges
• Any additional data you would ideally want to refine your analysis

Feedback Mechanism:

• After reviewing the candidate's work, provide specific feedback on their analytical approach, attention to data quality, and the clarity of their recommendations.
• Ask the candidate to refine one aspect of their analysis based on your feedback (e.g., adjusting a particular range that may be too broad or narrow, or addressing a market consideration they overlooked).
• Observe how receptively they incorporate feedback and their ability to adapt their approach.

Activity #2: Pay Equity Analysis Case Study

This exercise assesses a candidate's ability to identify potential pay disparities, analyze contributing factors, and develop remediation strategies. With increasing regulatory focus on pay equity and its importance to organizational culture, this skill is essential for modern Compensation Analysts.

Directions for the Company:

• Create a fictional dataset of 20-30 employees within a department, including variables such as:
• Current salary
• Job level/grade
• Performance ratings (for the past 1-2 years)
• Years of experience (total and in role)
• Education level
• Gender and other demographic information
• Hiring source (internal promotion vs. external hire)
• Intentionally build in some potential equity issues that require investigation.
• Provide a brief context about the fictional department and company.
• Allow 60-75 minutes for this exercise.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Analyze the provided employee data to identify any potential pay disparities or equity concerns.
• Determine which factors appear to be driving compensation differences.
• Prepare a brief presentation (5-7 slides) that:
• Outlines your methodology and key findings
• Identifies specific areas of concern
• Recommends immediate actions to address any inequities
• Suggests longer-term strategies to prevent future disparities
• Proposes metrics to monitor ongoing pay equity

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the candidate presents their analysis, provide feedback on both their analytical approach and communication style.
• Ask them to elaborate on one aspect of their remediation strategy, challenging them with a potential implementation obstacle.
• Evaluate how they respond to the challenge and their ability to think through practical implementation considerations.

Activity #3: Compensation Structure Design Exercise

This exercise evaluates a candidate's ability to design a comprehensive compensation program that aligns with business objectives. It tests their strategic thinking, knowledge of compensation components, and ability to balance competing priorities.

Directions for the Company:

• Create a scenario for a fictional company or department facing specific business challenges (e.g., high turnover, difficulty attracting talent, upcoming expansion, etc.).
• Provide relevant context such as:
• Industry and competitive landscape
• Current compensation approach and its limitations
• Budget constraints
• Business goals and priorities
• Employee demographics and feedback
• Allow 60 minutes for this exercise.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Design a comprehensive compensation strategy to address the business challenges presented.
• Your proposal should include:
• Base salary structure recommendations
• Variable pay components (if appropriate)
• Recognition programs
• Implementation timeline and communication strategy
• Cost projections and ROI considerations
• Metrics to evaluate program effectiveness
• Prepare a one-page executive summary and supporting documentation explaining your recommendations.

Feedback Mechanism:

• After reviewing the candidate's proposal, provide feedback on the strategic alignment, creativity, and practicality of their recommendations.
• Ask the candidate to refine one element of their proposal based on a new constraint or consideration you introduce (e.g., "What if the budget were reduced by 15%?" or "How would you modify this if we learned competitors were offering a specific benefit?").
• Evaluate their flexibility, prioritization skills, and ability to adapt their strategy while maintaining its core objectives.

Activity #4: Compensation Communication Role Play

This exercise assesses a candidate's ability to explain complex compensation concepts clearly and handle challenging conversations. Effective communication is crucial for Compensation Analysts who must partner with managers, executives, and employees to implement compensation programs successfully.

Directions for the Company:

• Prepare 2-3 role-play scenarios that Compensation Analysts commonly encounter, such as:
• Explaining a new compensation structure to managers
• Responding to a manager questioning why their employee can't receive a larger increase
• Discussing market pricing methodology with an executive who disagrees with the findings
• Explaining to an employee why their position is graded differently than they expected
• Provide relevant background information for each scenario.
• Allow candidates 15 minutes to prepare and 10-15 minutes for each role play.
• Assign someone to play the role of the manager, executive, or employee.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the scenario information provided.
• Prepare your approach to the conversation, considering:
• Key points you need to communicate
• Potential questions or objections you might encounter
• Data or examples you might reference
• Your communication style and tone
• During the role play, demonstrate your ability to:
• Explain complex compensation concepts in accessible language
• Listen actively and respond to concerns
• Maintain composure during challenging moments
• Balance empathy with organizational policies and constraints

Feedback Mechanism:

• After completing the role play, provide feedback on the candidate's communication clarity, empathy, and effectiveness in addressing concerns.
• Ask them to reflect on what they might do differently if they could redo part of the conversation.
• Give them an opportunity to demonstrate this adjustment in a brief follow-up scenario that builds on the original conversation.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long should we allocate for these work sample exercises?

Each exercise requires approximately 60-90 minutes, including time for the activity, feedback, and discussion. For remote candidates, consider spreading the exercises across multiple interview sessions. For on-site interviews, you might select 2-3 exercises that best align with your priorities for the role.

Should we provide these exercises to candidates in advance?

For Activities #1 and #3, providing the scenario 24-48 hours in advance allows candidates to showcase their best work without the pressure of an interview environment. Activities #2 and #4 are better conducted during the interview to assess how candidates think on their feet and handle pressure.

How should we evaluate candidates who have different approaches but equally valid results?

Focus on the candidate's reasoning and methodology rather than expecting a specific "right answer." The best candidates will be able to clearly articulate why they made certain decisions and demonstrate flexibility in their thinking when presented with new information or constraints.

What if a candidate has limited experience with certain compensation tools or methodologies?

Consider the candidate's learning agility and transferable skills. A candidate who demonstrates strong analytical thinking and can explain their approach clearly may quickly learn specific tools or methodologies. During feedback, observe how quickly they grasp and apply new concepts.

How can we make these exercises inclusive for candidates from different backgrounds?

Ensure that the scenarios and data provided don't require industry-specific knowledge that would disadvantage candidates from different sectors. Focus on fundamental compensation principles that transfer across industries. Also, be mindful of potential biases in how you evaluate responses and ensure multiple perspectives in the assessment process.

Should we share these exercises with internal candidates?

Yes, internal candidates should complete the same exercises as external candidates to ensure a fair comparison. However, you may need to anonymize company-specific data more thoroughly to prevent internal candidates from having an unfair advantage based on their knowledge of actual company practices.

Implementing these work sample exercises will significantly enhance your ability to identify top Compensation Analyst talent. By observing candidates tackle realistic challenges, you'll gain insights into their technical abilities, strategic thinking, and communication skills that simply cannot be assessed through traditional interviews alone.

Ready to take your hiring process to the next level? Yardstick offers comprehensive tools to help you design and implement effective hiring strategies for all your critical roles. From AI-powered job descriptions to customized interview questions and complete interview guides, we provide everything you need to make confident hiring decisions. Check out our Compensation Analyst job description for more insights into this critical role.

Build a complete interview guide for your Compensation Analyst role by signing up for a free Yardstick account