Effective Work Samples for Hiring Top Retail Banking Managers

The Retail Banking Manager role is pivotal to a financial institution's success, serving as the linchpin between strategic objectives and day-to-day operations. These leaders must excel across multiple domains: team leadership, sales performance, customer service, regulatory compliance, and community engagement. Traditional interviews often fail to reveal a candidate's true capabilities in these critical areas.

Work samples and role plays provide a window into how candidates will actually perform on the job, not just how well they interview. For Retail Banking Managers, these exercises reveal crucial insights about leadership style, decision-making processes, and problem-solving approaches that might otherwise remain hidden until after hiring.

The financial services industry faces unique challenges that require specific competencies. A candidate might present well in a standard interview but struggle with coaching underperforming team members, navigating complex regulatory requirements, or developing strategic plans to meet sales targets. Well-designed work samples expose these gaps before making a costly hiring mistake.

The following exercises are specifically designed to evaluate the essential competencies for Retail Banking Managers: leadership, customer orientation, strategic thinking, problem-solving, and communication. By implementing these activities in your interview process, you'll gain objective data to complement behavioral interviews and significantly improve your ability to identify candidates who will excel in this multifaceted role.

Activity #1: Team Coaching Role Play

This role play assesses a candidate's leadership abilities, coaching skills, and approach to performance management—critical competencies for effectively leading a branch team. The exercise reveals how candidates balance accountability with support and development, which directly impacts team performance and retention.

Directions for the Company:

• Select an employee scenario involving performance issues that a banking manager would typically encounter (e.g., a personal banker consistently missing sales targets, a teller with customer service complaints, or a team member struggling with compliance procedures).
• Provide the candidate with a brief written profile of the "employee" including performance history, strengths, weaknesses, and relevant background information 24 hours before the interview.
• Have an interviewer play the role of the underperforming employee. Create a script with typical responses and objections the "employee" might raise.
• Allocate 20 minutes for the coaching session followed by 10 minutes for feedback and discussion.
• Observe how the candidate balances addressing performance issues with maintaining employee engagement and development.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the employee profile provided and prepare for a coaching conversation.
• Conduct a 20-minute coaching session with the "employee" to address the performance issues.
• Your goals are to: identify the root causes of performance issues, provide constructive feedback, establish clear expectations, and develop an action plan for improvement.
• Be prepared to handle potential resistance or emotional responses from the employee.
• After the role play, you'll receive feedback and have an opportunity to reflect on your approach.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide specific feedback on the candidate's strengths (e.g., "You did an excellent job of asking open-ended questions to understand the employee's perspective").
• Offer one area for improvement (e.g., "You could be more specific about performance expectations and metrics").
• Allow the candidate 5 minutes to explain how they would adjust their approach based on the feedback.
• Evaluate their receptiveness to feedback and ability to adapt their coaching style.

Activity #2: Branch Performance Analysis and Strategy Development

This exercise evaluates a candidate's strategic thinking, analytical skills, and ability to develop actionable plans to improve branch performance—essential for driving business results in a competitive banking environment.

Directions for the Company:

• Create a fictional branch performance report including key metrics such as deposit growth, loan origination, customer satisfaction scores, cross-selling ratios, and operational efficiency measures. Include both strengths and areas for improvement.
• Include market data about the branch's location, competitive landscape, and customer demographics.
• Provide this information to candidates 24-48 hours before the interview.
• Ask candidates to prepare a 15-minute presentation outlining their analysis and strategic recommendations.
• Prepare challenging but realistic questions about their strategy to test their depth of understanding and ability to defend their recommendations.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the branch performance data and market information provided.
• Prepare a 15-minute presentation that includes:
• Analysis of the branch's current performance, identifying key strengths and challenges
• Prioritized list of 3-5 strategic initiatives to improve performance
• Specific action steps for implementing each initiative
• Key performance indicators you would track to measure success
• Timeline for implementation and expected results
• Be prepared to answer questions and defend your recommendations.
• Focus on realistic, practical solutions rather than theoretical approaches.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide feedback on the strength of the candidate's analysis and strategic thinking (e.g., "Your identification of the untapped small business market opportunity was insightful").
• Offer constructive feedback on one aspect of their plan (e.g., "Your timeline for implementing the new customer onboarding process may be too aggressive").
• Ask the candidate to revise that portion of their plan based on the feedback.
• Evaluate their ability to incorporate feedback while maintaining the integrity of their overall strategy.

Activity #3: Complex Customer Complaint Resolution

This scenario tests a candidate's customer orientation, problem-solving skills, and ability to balance customer satisfaction with bank policies—crucial for maintaining customer relationships while protecting the institution's interests.

Directions for the Company:

• Develop a detailed scenario involving a complex customer complaint that requires careful handling (e.g., a high-value customer threatening to leave due to a fee dispute, a business client experiencing issues with cash management services, or a customer claiming identity theft).
• Create a customer profile including relationship history, account information, and previous interactions.
• Prepare an interviewer to play the role of the upset customer, with a script of specific concerns and escalating emotions.
• Provide the candidate with basic information about the complaint 15 minutes before the exercise to allow for minimal preparation.
• Observe how the candidate balances empathy with policy adherence and problem resolution.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the customer complaint information provided.
• Conduct a 15-minute conversation with the customer to resolve their issue.
• Your goals are to: demonstrate empathy and active listening, identify the root cause of the problem, propose appropriate solutions within bank guidelines, and preserve the customer relationship.
• You'll have access to basic bank policies regarding fee structures, service standards, and escalation procedures.
• Be prepared to make decisions about potential exceptions or accommodations while considering both customer satisfaction and bank interests.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Highlight what the candidate did well in handling the customer (e.g., "Your empathetic approach and clear explanation of options effectively de-escalated the situation").
• Provide one area for improvement (e.g., "You could have been more proactive in offering solutions before the customer had to ask").
• Give the candidate 5 minutes to explain how they would handle a follow-up conversation with this customer based on the feedback.
• Assess their ability to incorporate feedback while maintaining their authentic customer service approach.

Activity #4: Community Partnership and Business Development Plan

This exercise evaluates a candidate's ability to develop community relationships and create strategic partnerships to drive business growth—a key differentiator for successful branch managers who must build the bank's presence in their local market.

Directions for the Company:

• Create a profile of a fictional community where the branch operates, including demographics, major employers, community organizations, and economic conditions.
• Provide information about the bank's current community involvement and business development initiatives.
• Include details about branch goals for new account acquisition, loan growth, and deposit increases.
• Give candidates this information 24-48 hours before the interview.
• Ask them to prepare a 2-page written plan and be ready to discuss it in a 15-minute conversation.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the community profile and branch goals provided.
• Develop a 2-page community partnership and business development plan that includes:
• Identification of 3-5 key partnership opportunities with local businesses, organizations, or community groups
• Specific strategies for leveraging these partnerships to achieve branch growth goals
• Outline of events, programs, or initiatives you would implement
• Resources required (budget, staff time, marketing materials)
• Expected outcomes and how you would measure success
• Be prepared to discuss your plan and answer questions about implementation details and potential challenges.
• Focus on realistic initiatives that balance community impact with business development.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide positive feedback on the strongest aspects of their plan (e.g., "Your strategy for partnering with the local chamber of commerce shows strong business acumen").
• Offer one constructive suggestion for improvement (e.g., "Your plan could benefit from more specific metrics to measure the ROI of these community initiatives").
• Ask the candidate to verbally revise that portion of their plan based on the feedback.
• Evaluate their ability to incorporate the feedback while maintaining the core strengths of their original approach.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long should we allocate for these work samples in our interview process?

Each activity requires approximately 30-45 minutes including preparation, execution, feedback, and evaluation. We recommend selecting 1-2 activities most relevant to your specific branch needs rather than attempting all four. The Team Coaching Role Play and Branch Performance Analysis are particularly high-yield for evaluating core competencies.

Should we use the same work sample for all candidates to ensure fair comparison?

Yes, using consistent scenarios allows for direct comparison between candidates. However, you can customize the specific details (employee profile, branch metrics, etc.) to reflect your bank's actual challenges while maintaining the same fundamental exercise structure.

How should we weight these work samples compared to traditional interviews?

Work samples typically provide higher predictive validity than traditional interviews. We recommend they account for 40-50% of your overall evaluation, with behavioral interviews and reference checks comprising the remainder. The specific weighting may vary based on which competencies are most critical for your particular branch.

What if a candidate performs poorly on a work sample but excels in traditional interviews?

This discrepancy often reveals important insights. Consider whether the work sample exposed genuine skill gaps or if the candidate simply needs more context to succeed in your environment. For critical competencies like leadership or customer orientation, strong work sample performance should generally outweigh interview impressions.

How can we make these exercises feel less artificial and more reflective of our actual work environment?

Customize scenarios to reflect real challenges your branch has faced. Use actual branch performance data with identifying information removed. Have your team members who regularly interact with the branch manager play the roles of employees or customers to create authentic interactions.

Can these exercises be conducted virtually for remote interviews?

Yes, all four activities can be adapted for virtual settings. For role plays, use video conferencing. For written exercises and presentations, use screen sharing. The key is maintaining the interactive elements and ensuring technology doesn't become a barrier to authentic assessment.

The hiring process for a Retail Banking Manager deserves significant investment, as this role directly impacts branch performance, team engagement, and customer satisfaction. By incorporating these work samples into your interview process, you'll gain invaluable insights into how candidates will actually perform in the role, not just how well they interview.

For more resources to enhance your hiring process, check out Yardstick's AI Job Description Generator, AI Interview Question Generator, and AI Interview Guide Generator. You can also find a complete example job description for a Retail Banking Manager here.

Ready to build a complete interview guide for this role? Sign up for a free Yardstick account