Effective Work Samples for Hiring an Exceptional Agile Coach

Hiring the right Agile Coach is a critical decision that can significantly impact your organization's agile transformation journey. An effective Agile Coach serves as a catalyst for change, guiding teams and leadership through the complexities of adopting and optimizing agile methodologies. They must possess a unique blend of technical knowledge, coaching abilities, facilitation skills, and strategic thinking.

Traditional interviews often fail to reveal a candidate's true capabilities in these areas. While candidates may articulate agile principles eloquently, their ability to apply these concepts in real-world scenarios—where team dynamics, organizational resistance, and practical challenges come into play—remains untested in a standard question-and-answer format.

Work samples and role plays provide a window into how candidates actually perform in situations they'll encounter on the job. For an Agile Coach, these exercises reveal their coaching approach, facilitation style, problem-solving abilities, and how they handle resistance to change—all critical competencies that determine success in this role.

The following work samples are designed to evaluate candidates across the essential dimensions of agile coaching: mentoring team members, facilitating effective ceremonies, developing strategic transformation plans, and influencing stakeholders at all levels. By observing candidates in action through these exercises, you'll gain valuable insights that go far beyond what resumes and traditional interviews can reveal.

Activity #1: Coaching a Struggling Scrum Master

This role play assesses a candidate's coaching abilities—a fundamental skill for any Agile Coach. Effective coaches don't simply dictate solutions; they ask powerful questions that help individuals discover insights and develop their own problem-solving capabilities. This exercise reveals how candidates build rapport, identify root causes, and guide others toward improvement while maintaining their autonomy and confidence.

Directions for the Company:

• Select an employee to play the role of a struggling Scrum Master who is facing specific challenges (script provided below).
• Provide the candidate with a brief background on the fictional Scrum Master and their team's situation 30 minutes before the exercise.
• The role play should last 20-25 minutes, followed by 5-10 minutes for feedback.
• The person playing the Scrum Master should follow the script but respond naturally to the candidate's coaching approach.
• Script example: "You're a new Scrum Master for a team that consistently misses sprint commitments. Team members often work in silos, daily standups run long with technical discussions, and the Product Owner frequently changes priorities mid-sprint."

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the background information about the Scrum Master and their team.
• Conduct a coaching session to help the Scrum Master identify and address their challenges.
• Focus on asking effective questions rather than simply providing solutions.
• Help the Scrum Master develop an action plan they can implement.
• Your goal is to demonstrate your coaching approach and ability to guide others toward improvement without taking over their responsibilities.

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the role play, the interviewer should provide feedback on one aspect the candidate handled effectively and one area for improvement.
• The candidate will then have 5 minutes to reflect on how they would adjust their approach based on the feedback.
• Ask the candidate to demonstrate a brief follow-up question or technique they would use differently based on the feedback.

Activity #2: Agile Ceremony Facilitation

This exercise evaluates the candidate's ability to design and facilitate effective agile ceremonies—a core responsibility of Agile Coaches. Great facilitators create environments where teams can collaborate productively, stay focused on objectives, and generate meaningful outcomes. This activity reveals the candidate's preparation process, facilitation techniques, and ability to handle common challenges that arise during team ceremonies.

Directions for the Company:

• Provide the candidate with a scenario: "A team has been struggling with ineffective retrospectives. Team members are reluctant to speak up, the same issues are raised repeatedly without resolution, and the meetings often feel like a waste of time."
• Give the candidate 45 minutes to prepare a 20-minute retrospective facilitation.
• Have 3-4 employees play the role of team members with specific personalities (e.g., dominant speaker, silent observer, negative participant).
• Brief these employees on their roles before the exercise.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Design a retrospective format that addresses the challenges described in the scenario.
• Prepare any materials, activities, or techniques you would use.
• Facilitate a 20-minute portion of the retrospective with the mock team.
• Your goal is to create psychological safety, ensure balanced participation, and guide the team toward actionable outcomes.
• Be prepared to handle the different personalities and dynamics that emerge during the session.

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the facilitation, the interviewer should highlight one strength in the candidate's approach and one area for improvement.
• The candidate will have 10 minutes to adjust their facilitation plan based on the feedback.
• Ask the candidate to briefly demonstrate how they would implement this change if they were to continue or restart the retrospective.

Activity #3: Agile Transformation Strategy

This exercise assesses the candidate's strategic thinking and ability to plan complex organizational change—essential for driving successful agile transformations. Effective Agile Coaches must balance theoretical knowledge with practical implementation strategies that account for organizational realities. This activity reveals how candidates approach large-scale change, prioritize initiatives, and address potential obstacles.

Directions for the Company:

• Provide the candidate with a case study of a fictional organization seeking to transform from traditional project management to agile methodologies.
• Include details about the organization's structure, current processes, business goals, and specific challenges (e.g., distributed teams, regulatory requirements, legacy systems).
• Give the candidate 60 minutes to prepare a 15-minute presentation of their transformation strategy.
• Prepare questions that probe the candidate's reasoning and ability to adapt the plan to changing circumstances.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the case study materials and develop a 12-month agile transformation strategy.
• Your strategy should include:
• Assessment of the organization's current state and readiness for change
• Recommended approach (e.g., pilot teams vs. organization-wide)
• Key milestones and success metrics
• Training and coaching plan
• Potential risks and mitigation strategies
• Prepare a 15-minute presentation of your strategy for the interview panel.
• Be prepared to answer questions and defend your recommendations.

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the presentation, interviewers should provide feedback on one strong element of the strategy and one area that could be strengthened.
• Give the candidate 10 minutes to revise one aspect of their plan based on the feedback.
• Ask the candidate to explain how this revision improves the overall transformation strategy.

Activity #4: Stakeholder Resistance Scenario

This role play evaluates the candidate's ability to influence stakeholders and navigate resistance to change—critical skills for driving agile adoption across an organization. Effective Agile Coaches must communicate persuasively with leaders who may have different priorities and concerns. This exercise reveals how candidates build credibility, address objections, and adapt their message to different audiences.

Directions for the Company:

• Select an employee to play the role of a resistant senior manager (script provided below).
• Provide the candidate with background information about the fictional manager's concerns and organizational context 30 minutes before the exercise.
• The role play should last 15-20 minutes, followed by 10 minutes for feedback.
• Script example: "You're a senior engineering manager who believes agile is just another management fad. Your teams have always delivered using traditional methods, and you're concerned that agile will reduce predictability and documentation. You're also worried about losing control and visibility into what your teams are doing."

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the background information about the senior manager and their concerns.
• Prepare for a conversation aimed at addressing their resistance to agile adoption.
• Your goal is not to "win an argument" but to understand their perspective, address legitimate concerns, and find common ground.
• Be prepared to explain the benefits of agile in terms that resonate with their priorities and values.
• Demonstrate how you would influence without authority in this situation.

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the role play, the interviewer should provide feedback on one effective aspect of the candidate's approach and one area for improvement.
• The candidate will have 5 minutes to reflect on the feedback.
• Ask the candidate to demonstrate how they would handle a specific part of the conversation differently based on the feedback received.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long should we allocate for these work samples in our interview process?

Each exercise requires approximately 60-90 minutes, including preparation, execution, and feedback. We recommend selecting 1-2 exercises that best align with your organization's priorities rather than attempting all four in a single interview day. The Coaching and Facilitation exercises work well together, as do the Transformation Strategy and Stakeholder Resistance scenarios.

Should we provide materials to candidates in advance?

For the Transformation Strategy exercise, consider providing the case study 24-48 hours in advance to allow for thoughtful preparation. For the other exercises, providing materials 30-60 minutes before the activity strikes a good balance between preparation and assessing the candidate's ability to think on their feet.

How should we evaluate candidates across these exercises?

Create a structured scorecard for each exercise that aligns with the key competencies in your job description. Rate candidates on specific behaviors rather than general impressions. For example, in the coaching exercise, evaluate how well they asked open-ended questions, listened actively, and helped the Scrum Master develop their own solutions.

What if we don't have employees who can effectively play the roles needed?

If you don't have employees available who can consistently play these roles, consider hiring professional role players or asking your recruiting firm to provide this service. Alternatively, the hiring manager or HR professional can play these roles with a prepared script to ensure consistency across candidates.

How do we ensure consistency when evaluating different candidates?

Standardize as many elements as possible: use the same scenarios, scripts, role players, and evaluation criteria for all candidates. Have the same interviewers observe each candidate if possible. Document specific examples of candidate behaviors rather than relying on memory when comparing candidates later.

Can these exercises be conducted remotely?

Yes, all of these exercises can be adapted for remote interviews using video conferencing tools. For the facilitation exercise, provide access to virtual collaboration tools (e.g., Miro, Mural) that the candidate can use to design their retrospective activities.

Finding the right Agile Coach can dramatically accelerate your organization's agile journey and help you realize the benefits of increased adaptability, faster delivery, and higher quality outcomes. By incorporating these work samples into your hiring process, you'll gain deeper insights into candidates' real-world capabilities and identify those who can truly drive meaningful transformation in your organization.

Ready to take your hiring process to the next level? Yardstick offers AI-powered tools to help you create customized job descriptions, interview questions, and comprehensive interview guides tailored to your specific needs. Learn more about how we can help you find your ideal Agile Coach at yardstick.team/job-description/agile-coach.

Build a complete interview guide for this role by signing up for a free Yardstick account here