Effective Work Samples for Assessing AI Tool Evaluation Skills in Candidates

In today's rapidly evolving technological landscape, the ability to effectively evaluate AI tools for business applications has become a critical skill for organizations seeking competitive advantage. Companies are increasingly relying on professionals who can navigate the complex AI marketplace, identify solutions that align with business objectives, and implement them successfully while managing associated risks.

The challenge for hiring managers lies in accurately assessing a candidate's proficiency in evaluating AI tools beyond what's listed on their resume. While candidates may claim expertise in AI evaluation, their actual ability to analyze options, understand technical capabilities, align tools with business needs, and consider implementation factors can only be verified through practical demonstration.

Work samples provide an authentic window into how candidates approach AI tool evaluation in real-world scenarios. By observing candidates as they analyze options, develop frameworks, and communicate recommendations, hiring managers can gain valuable insights into their analytical thinking, technical understanding, business acumen, and communication skills.

The following four work sample activities are designed to comprehensively assess a candidate's ability to evaluate AI tools for business use. These exercises simulate common scenarios professionals face when tasked with selecting and implementing AI solutions, allowing hiring managers to make more informed decisions about which candidates possess the practical skills needed for success in this critical area.

Activity #1: Comparative AI Tool Analysis

This activity assesses a candidate's ability to systematically compare AI tools against specific business requirements. It demonstrates their analytical thinking, technical understanding, and ability to align technology capabilities with business needs. Candidates must evaluate multiple AI solutions, identify strengths and weaknesses, and make a recommendation based on defined criteria.

Directions for the Company:

• Prepare a brief business case scenario describing a specific business function that needs improvement (e.g., customer service, sales forecasting, content creation).
• Provide information about three different AI tools that could potentially address this need, including features, pricing, integration capabilities, and limitations.
• Create a set of business requirements and constraints (budget, timeline, technical environment) that the ideal solution should meet.
• Allow 45-60 minutes for this exercise.
• Provide access to a computer with internet access for research if needed.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the business scenario and requirements carefully.
• Analyze the three AI tools provided against the business requirements.
• Create a comparison matrix or framework that clearly shows how each tool performs against key criteria.
• Prepare a 10-minute presentation explaining your analysis and recommending the most suitable tool.
• Be prepared to justify your recommendation and discuss trade-offs.

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the presentation, provide feedback on one aspect the candidate did well (e.g., thoroughness of analysis, clarity of communication) and one area for improvement (e.g., consideration of implementation challenges, depth of technical understanding).
• Ask the candidate to spend 5 minutes addressing the improvement area by revising part of their recommendation or addressing additional considerations.

Activity #2: AI Implementation Business Case Development

This activity evaluates a candidate's ability to build a compelling business case for AI implementation, demonstrating their understanding of ROI calculation, change management considerations, and ability to connect technical capabilities to business value. It tests both analytical and communication skills essential for successful AI adoption.

Directions for the Company:

• Create a scenario describing a business challenge that could be addressed with AI (e.g., inefficient document processing, customer churn prediction, inventory management).
• Provide relevant business metrics and data points (current process costs, error rates, time requirements).
• Include information about stakeholders who would be affected by the implementation.
• Allow 60 minutes for this exercise.
• Provide a template for the business case if desired.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Develop a business case for implementing an AI solution to address the described challenge.
• Include the following components:
• Executive summary
• Problem statement and current state analysis
• Proposed AI solution and implementation approach
• Expected benefits (quantitative and qualitative)
• Cost analysis and ROI calculation
• Implementation timeline and key milestones
• Risk assessment and mitigation strategies
• Prepare to present your business case in 15 minutes.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide feedback on one strength (e.g., thoroughness of ROI analysis, clarity of value proposition) and one area for improvement (e.g., risk assessment, stakeholder considerations).
• Ask the candidate to spend 10 minutes enhancing the area identified for improvement.
• Observe how they incorporate feedback and strengthen their business case.

Activity #3: AI Evaluation Framework Creation

This activity assesses a candidate's ability to develop a structured approach to evaluating AI tools, demonstrating their systematic thinking and understanding of the multifaceted considerations involved in AI tool selection. It reveals how candidates prioritize different factors and create processes that can be consistently applied across various AI evaluation scenarios.

Directions for the Company:

• Explain that the organization needs a standardized framework for evaluating AI tools across different departments.
• Provide information about the organization's technology environment, security requirements, and business priorities.
• Mention any previous challenges encountered with technology adoption.
• Allow 45 minutes for this exercise.
• Provide examples of criteria that might be important (optional).

Directions for the Candidate:

• Develop a comprehensive framework for evaluating AI tools that could be used across the organization.
• Your framework should include:
• Key evaluation categories (e.g., technical capabilities, integration, security, cost, vendor stability)
• Specific criteria within each category
• Weighting or prioritization system
• Scoring methodology
• Process for gathering inputs from stakeholders
• Documentation approach
• Create a visual representation of your framework (flowchart, matrix, or other format).
• Prepare to explain how this framework would be applied in practice in a 10-minute presentation.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide feedback on one strength (e.g., comprehensiveness of criteria, practicality of application) and one area for improvement (e.g., stakeholder engagement process, technical depth).
• Ask the candidate to spend 5-10 minutes enhancing the identified area for improvement.
• Have them explain how the revised framework addresses the feedback.

Activity #4: AI Ethics and Risk Assessment

This activity evaluates a candidate's ability to identify and address ethical considerations and risks associated with AI implementation. It demonstrates their awareness of responsible AI practices, regulatory considerations, and ability to develop mitigation strategies for potential issues that could impact business reputation and operations.

Directions for the Company:

• Create a scenario describing an AI implementation with potential ethical implications (e.g., AI-powered hiring tool, customer behavior prediction system, automated decision-making system).
• Provide details about the data the system would use and decisions it would influence.
• Include information about the industry and relevant regulations.
• Allow 45-60 minutes for this exercise.
• Provide access to reference materials on AI ethics if desired.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the AI implementation scenario and identify potential ethical concerns and risks, including:
• Data privacy and security issues
• Bias and fairness considerations
• Transparency and explainability challenges
• Regulatory compliance requirements
• Potential unintended consequences
• Develop a comprehensive risk assessment matrix that categorizes risks by severity and likelihood.
• Create a mitigation plan for the top 3-5 identified risks.
• Prepare a 15-minute presentation of your findings and recommendations.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide feedback on one strength (e.g., thoroughness of risk identification, practicality of mitigation strategies) and one area for improvement (e.g., consideration of specific regulations, stakeholder impact analysis).
• Ask the candidate to spend 10 minutes enhancing their risk assessment or mitigation plan based on the feedback.
• Have them explain how their revised approach addresses the concerns raised.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much time should we allocate for these work samples in our interview process?

Each activity requires 45-60 minutes for completion plus 15-20 minutes for presentation and feedback. Consider using one or two activities rather than all four if time is limited. The Comparative AI Tool Analysis and AI Ethics and Risk Assessment activities provide a good balance of technical and strategic evaluation skills if you need to choose.

Should candidates be allowed to use the internet during these exercises?

Yes, allowing internet access creates a more realistic scenario since professionals typically research tools and best practices. However, be clear about expectations regarding what resources they can use. For the Comparative AI Tool Analysis, you might want to provide specific information about the tools to ensure candidates focus on analysis rather than research.

How technical should candidates be to complete these exercises successfully?

These exercises are designed to assess business-focused AI evaluation skills rather than deep technical expertise. Candidates should understand AI capabilities and limitations but don't need to be data scientists or engineers. Adjust the technical depth based on the specific role requirements.

Can these exercises be completed remotely or as take-home assignments?

Yes, all four activities can be adapted for remote interviews or take-home assignments. For remote interviews, use screen sharing for presentations. For take-home assignments, provide clear instructions about deliverables and time expectations, but be aware that you'll miss observing the candidate's real-time problem-solving approach.

How should we evaluate candidates who have experience with different AI tools than those in our scenarios?

Focus on evaluating the candidate's approach to assessment rather than their familiarity with specific tools. Their methodology, critical thinking, and ability to identify relevant criteria are more important than prior knowledge of particular AI solutions. The exercises test transferable evaluation skills that apply across different AI technologies.

Should we customize these exercises for different industries or company sizes?

Yes, tailoring these activities to your industry, company size, and specific AI use cases will make them more relevant and effective. Adjust the scenarios, requirements, and evaluation criteria to reflect your organization's context and the specific challenges you're likely to face when implementing AI solutions.

The ability to effectively evaluate AI tools for business use is becoming increasingly critical as organizations across industries seek to leverage artificial intelligence for competitive advantage. By incorporating these practical work samples into your hiring process, you can more accurately assess candidates' capabilities in this important skill area and identify those who will drive successful AI adoption in your organization.

For more resources to enhance your hiring process, explore Yardstick's suite of AI-powered tools, including our AI Job Descriptions, AI Interview Question Generator, and AI Interview Guide Generator.

Ready to build a complete interview guide for evaluating AI tool assessment skills? Sign up for a free Yardstick account today!