Effective Work Sample Exercises for Hiring Payment Operations Specialists

Payment Operations Specialists serve as the guardians of your company's financial integrity, protecting both your business and customers from fraud while ensuring smooth payment processes. The importance of hiring the right person for this role cannot be overstated, as they will handle sensitive financial information, resolve complex disputes, and serve as the first line of defense against fraudulent activities.

Traditional interviews often fail to reveal a candidate's true capabilities in handling the day-to-day challenges of payment operations. While resumes may highlight experience with KYC processes or chargeback resolution, they don't demonstrate how candidates perform these tasks in real-world scenarios. This is where practical work samples become invaluable.

Well-designed work samples allow you to observe candidates' analytical thinking, attention to detail, problem-solving abilities, and customer service skills in action. For Payment Operations Specialists, who spend 60-80% of their time performing KYC checks and the remainder investigating suspicious activities and resolving disputes, these practical exercises provide insight into their technical knowledge and approach to complex situations.

The following work samples are specifically designed to evaluate the core competencies required for a Payment Operations Specialist: conducting thorough KYC checks, managing payment disputes, identifying fraudulent activities, and providing excellent customer service. By incorporating these exercises into your interview process, you'll be able to make more informed hiring decisions and identify candidates who can truly excel in this critical role.

Activity #1: KYC Documentation Review and Risk Assessment

This exercise evaluates a candidate's ability to conduct thorough KYC checks, which is the primary responsibility of a Payment Operations Specialist. It tests their attention to detail, analytical thinking, and knowledge of compliance requirements. Candidates will need to review customer documentation, identify potential red flags, and make appropriate risk assessments.

Directions for the Company:

• Prepare a mock customer onboarding file that includes various identification documents (passport/ID, proof of address, business registration if applicable) with deliberate inconsistencies or red flags embedded.
• Include some subtle issues (slight name spelling differences between documents), some moderate concerns (address discrepancies), and one or two significant red flags (potentially altered document, suspicious business structure).
• Provide access to a simplified version of your KYC verification checklist or guidelines.
• Allow 30-45 minutes for this exercise.
• Have a scoring rubric that evaluates: thoroughness of review, identification of key issues, appropriate risk classification, and clarity of documentation.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the provided customer documentation as if you were processing a new customer onboarding request.
• Complete the KYC verification checklist, noting any discrepancies, missing information, or potential red flags.
• Assign a risk level to the customer (Low, Medium, High) based on your findings.
• Document your reasoning for the risk assessment and recommend next steps (approve, request additional information, or reject).
• Be prepared to explain your decision-making process and how you prioritized different issues.

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the candidate completes their assessment, review their findings and discuss which issues they identified correctly and which they missed.
• Provide specific feedback on one aspect they handled well (perhaps thoroughness or clear documentation) and one area for improvement (perhaps risk assessment reasoning).
• Ask the candidate to reconsider their risk classification based on the feedback and explain how they would adjust their approach for future verifications.

Activity #2: Chargeback Investigation and Resolution

This exercise tests the candidate's ability to investigate payment disputes, analyze transaction data, and communicate effectively with customers. It evaluates their problem-solving skills, customer orientation, and knowledge of chargeback processes, which are essential for the dispute resolution aspects of the role.

Directions for the Company:

• Create a realistic chargeback scenario with supporting documentation, including:
• The original transaction details
• The customer's chargeback claim (reason code and explanation)
• Available evidence (transaction logs, delivery confirmation, communication history)
• Your company's chargeback response template
• Include some contradictory information that requires careful analysis.
• Allow 30-40 minutes for this exercise.
• Prepare to role-play as the customer if the candidate needs to request additional information.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the chargeback case and all supporting documentation.
• Identify what additional information, if any, you would need to properly investigate this dispute.
• Determine whether the chargeback is valid or should be contested.
• Draft a response to the payment processor defending your position (if contesting) or explaining the resolution (if accepting).
• Prepare a separate communication to the customer explaining the outcome and next steps.
• Be ready to explain your reasoning and the factors that influenced your decision.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide feedback on the thoroughness of their investigation and the clarity of their written communications.
• Highlight one strength in their approach (perhaps their analytical process or customer-focused language).
• Suggest one improvement area (perhaps overlooking a key piece of evidence or using overly technical language with the customer).
• Ask the candidate to revise either their processor response or customer communication based on your feedback.

Activity #3: Fraud Pattern Detection Exercise

This exercise evaluates the candidate's ability to identify suspicious patterns in transaction data, a critical skill for protecting the company from fraud. It tests their analytical thinking, attention to detail, and knowledge of common fraud indicators.

Directions for the Company:

• Create a spreadsheet of transaction data (50-100 transactions) that includes various data points: transaction amount, time, location, device information, customer history, etc.
• Embed several fraud patterns of varying obviousness, such as:
• Multiple high-value transactions from the same device in different locations
• Unusual transaction timing patterns
• Suspicious velocity patterns (rapid small transactions followed by larger ones)
• Transactions from high-risk regions
• Provide basic information about your typical customer transaction patterns.
• Allow 30-45 minutes for this exercise.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the transaction data set to identify potential fraudulent activities.
• Flag suspicious transactions and explain why you consider them suspicious.
• Identify any patterns or connections between transactions that might indicate organized fraud.
• Recommend actions for each flagged transaction (approve, decline, hold for further review).
• Suggest what additional data points would help you make more confident assessments.
• Prepare a brief summary of the fraud patterns you identified and their potential impact.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Review which fraud patterns the candidate successfully identified and which they missed.
• Provide positive feedback on their analytical approach or pattern recognition abilities.
• Offer constructive feedback on an area they could improve (perhaps overlooking a subtle pattern or making assumptions without sufficient evidence).
• Ask the candidate to explain how they would implement a monitoring system to automatically detect one of the patterns they missed.

Activity #4: Customer Dispute Resolution Role Play

This role play assesses the candidate's customer service skills, empathy, and ability to handle difficult conversations while maintaining compliance with policies. It evaluates how they balance customer satisfaction with fraud prevention and company policies.

Directions for the Company:

• Prepare a scenario involving a frustrated customer with a complex payment issue (e.g., a legitimate transaction flagged as fraudulent, a subscription billing dispute, or a payment processing delay).
• Create a customer profile with relevant transaction history and account notes.
• Outline your company's relevant policies and procedures for this type of situation.
• Have someone play the role of the upset customer, with specific talking points and objections prepared.
• Allow 15-20 minutes for the role play.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the customer profile and issue details before the call.
• Handle the customer call professionally, addressing their concerns while following company policies.
• Investigate the issue during the conversation, asking appropriate questions to gather necessary information.
• Explain the situation clearly to the customer, avoiding technical jargon.
• Propose a resolution that balances customer satisfaction with company policies and fraud prevention.
• Document the interaction and resolution as you would in your actual work.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide feedback on their communication style, empathy, problem-solving approach, and adherence to policies.
• Highlight one aspect of the interaction they handled particularly well (perhaps de-escalation or clear explanation).
• Suggest one area for improvement (perhaps being more assertive about policy requirements or showing more empathy).
• Give the candidate an opportunity to reflect on how they would handle a specific moment in the conversation differently based on your feedback.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long should each work sample take to complete?

Each exercise is designed to take 30-45 minutes, with the role play being slightly shorter at 15-20 minutes. We recommend scheduling separate sessions for these exercises rather than trying to complete all four in one sitting, which would be overwhelming for candidates.

Should we use real customer data for these exercises?

No, never use real customer data for interview exercises. Create fictional scenarios that mirror real situations but use made-up names, accounts, and transaction details. This protects customer privacy and confidentiality while still providing a realistic assessment.

How should we evaluate candidates who have experience with different payment systems than what we use?

Focus on the underlying principles and processes rather than specific system knowledge. A strong candidate will demonstrate sound judgment, analytical thinking, and problem-solving skills regardless of the specific tools they've used previously. Technical systems can be learned, but core competencies like attention to detail and analytical thinking are harder to teach.

Should we give candidates access to reference materials during these exercises?

Yes, providing basic reference materials (like KYC guidelines or chargeback reason codes) is recommended. This creates a more realistic work environment and tests their ability to apply information rather than memorize it. However, the exercises should still challenge their core skills and judgment.

How do we ensure these exercises don't disadvantage candidates from different backgrounds?

Review your exercises to ensure they don't require specific cultural knowledge or contain biases. Focus on universal skills like analytical thinking, attention to detail, and clear communication. Provide sufficient context and background information so all candidates start with the same understanding of the scenario.

Can these exercises be conducted remotely?

Yes, all of these exercises can be adapted for remote interviews. For the KYC review and fraud detection exercises, use screen sharing or secure document sharing. For the role play, video conferencing works well. Just ensure candidates have the necessary technology and a quiet environment before scheduling.

The Payment Operations Specialist role is critical to maintaining the financial integrity of your organization and protecting both your company and customers. By incorporating these practical work samples into your hiring process, you'll be able to identify candidates who not only have the technical knowledge but also possess the analytical thinking, attention to detail, and customer service skills needed to excel in this position.

Remember that the best hiring decisions come from combining these work samples with structured behavioral interviews and thorough reference checks. For additional resources to enhance your hiring process, check out our AI Job Description Generator, AI Interview Question Generator, and AI Interview Guide Generator. You can also find a comprehensive job description for this role at our Payment Operations Specialist Job Description page.

Build a complete interview guide for this role by signing up for a free Yardstick account