Effective Work Sample Exercises for Hiring an AI Ethics Consultant

In the rapidly evolving landscape of artificial intelligence, organizations face increasing pressure to implement AI systems that are not only innovative but also ethically sound. An AI Ethics Consultant serves as the critical bridge between technological advancement and ethical responsibility, ensuring that AI implementations align with organizational values, regulatory requirements, and societal expectations.

Finding the right AI Ethics Consultant requires more than reviewing resumes and conducting standard interviews. The complexity of this role demands a practical assessment of how candidates approach real-world ethical dilemmas in AI. Traditional interview methods often fail to reveal a candidate's true capabilities in identifying subtle ethical risks, developing comprehensive frameworks, and effectively communicating complex ethical concepts to diverse stakeholders.

Work samples provide a window into how candidates actually perform the core responsibilities of an AI Ethics Consultant. By observing candidates as they analyze ethical implications, develop guidelines, and communicate recommendations, hiring teams can make more informed decisions based on demonstrated skills rather than self-reported experience.

The following exercises are designed to evaluate candidates across the essential competencies required for success in this role: analytical thinking, ethical judgment, communication skills, collaborative mindset, and adaptability. Each exercise simulates a realistic scenario that AI Ethics Consultants commonly encounter, allowing you to assess how candidates would perform in your organization.

Activity #1: Ethical Risk Assessment of a Facial Recognition System

This exercise evaluates a candidate's ability to identify potential ethical risks in an AI system and prioritize concerns based on severity and likelihood. Facial recognition technology presents numerous ethical challenges including privacy concerns, bias issues, and potential misuse—making it an ideal subject for ethical analysis.

Directions for the Company:

• Prepare a brief (1-2 page) description of a hypothetical facial recognition system your company is considering implementing. Include details about:
• The system's intended purpose (e.g., security access, customer identification)
• Technical specifications (accuracy rates across different demographics)
• Proposed deployment context (public spaces, private facilities)
• Data collection and retention policies
• Provide relevant company policies or values statements that might inform ethical considerations
• Allow candidates 45-60 minutes to review materials and prepare their assessment
• Have a technical team member and a business stakeholder present during the exercise to observe how the candidate balances technical and business considerations

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the provided materials about the facial recognition system
• Identify at least 5 potential ethical risks or concerns with the proposed implementation
• Categorize each risk by severity (high/medium/low) and likelihood
• Prepare a 10-minute presentation of your findings, focusing on:
• The most critical ethical concerns
• The ethical principles or frameworks you applied in your analysis
• Initial recommendations for addressing the top 2-3 concerns
• Be prepared to answer questions about your methodology and reasoning

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the presentation, provide specific feedback on one strength of the candidate's analysis (e.g., thoroughness of risk identification, clarity of ethical principles applied)
• Offer one area for improvement (e.g., consideration of additional stakeholder perspectives, deeper analysis of a particular risk)
• Ask the candidate to spend 5-10 minutes revising their top recommendation based on the feedback provided

Activity #2: Ethical Framework Development

This exercise assesses a candidate's ability to develop structured ethical guidelines that can be practically implemented across an organization. Creating frameworks that balance ethical considerations with business objectives is a core responsibility of an AI Ethics Consultant.

Directions for the Company:

• Prepare a brief overview of a specific AI domain your company works in (e.g., recommendation systems, predictive analytics, natural language processing)
• Include information about:
• Types of data typically used
• Common applications within your organization
• Any existing ethical guidelines or principles
• Key stakeholders involved in development and deployment
• Provide 2-3 examples of ethical challenges previously encountered
• Allow candidates 60-90 minutes to develop their framework
• Have representatives from both technical and policy teams available to answer clarifying questions

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the provided materials about the AI domain
• Develop a comprehensive ethical framework that includes:
• Core ethical principles relevant to this domain
• Specific guidelines for different stages of the AI lifecycle (design, development, deployment, monitoring)
• Governance mechanisms for ensuring adherence
• Metrics for measuring ethical performance
• Create a one-page visual representation of your framework that could be used to communicate it across the organization
• Prepare a 15-minute presentation explaining your framework and implementation approach

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide feedback on the framework's comprehensiveness and practical applicability
• Highlight one aspect that would be particularly valuable to the organization
• Suggest one area where the framework might face implementation challenges
• Ask the candidate to spend 10 minutes addressing how they would overcome the identified implementation challenge

Activity #3: Cross-Functional Collaboration Role Play

This exercise evaluates a candidate's ability to navigate competing priorities and effectively collaborate with stakeholders who may have different perspectives on ethical considerations. The ability to build consensus while maintaining ethical standards is crucial for an AI Ethics Consultant.

Directions for the Company:

• Prepare a scenario involving an AI project with competing priorities:
• A product team eager to launch a new AI feature quickly
• A legal team concerned about regulatory compliance
• A data science team focused on model performance
• Business stakeholders concerned about competitive advantage
• Assign 3-4 team members to play these different stakeholders, each with specific concerns and objectives
• Provide the scenario to candidates 24 hours in advance
• Allow 30-45 minutes for the role play exercise

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the scenario and prepare for a cross-functional meeting where you'll need to:
• Listen to concerns from different stakeholders
• Identify areas of ethical risk
• Facilitate a discussion toward consensus
• Propose a path forward that addresses ethical concerns while respecting business objectives
• During the meeting, demonstrate your ability to:
• Ask clarifying questions to understand stakeholder perspectives
• Articulate ethical principles in business-relevant terms
• Find creative solutions that address multiple concerns
• Build consensus around ethically sound approaches

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the role play, provide feedback on the candidate's facilitation skills and ability to articulate ethical concerns effectively
• Highlight one particularly effective strategy they used to build consensus
• Suggest one approach that might have better addressed a specific stakeholder's concerns
• Ask the candidate to spend 5 minutes explaining how they would modify their approach based on this feedback

Activity #4: Ethical Incident Response Planning

This exercise assesses a candidate's ability to develop proactive strategies for addressing ethical incidents when they occur. Preparing for potential ethical failures demonstrates foresight and practical risk management—essential skills for an AI Ethics Consultant.

Directions for the Company:

• Create a scenario describing an AI system that has experienced an ethical failure:
• A recommendation algorithm showing bias against certain user groups
• A decision-making system that cannot explain critical decisions
• A data privacy breach in an AI application
• Include details about:
• The nature and scope of the incident
• Initial public or user reaction
• Potential regulatory implications
• Business impact
• Provide relevant company policies and values statements
• Allow candidates 60 minutes to develop their response plan

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the ethical incident scenario
• Develop a comprehensive incident response plan that includes:
• Immediate actions to mitigate harm
• Investigation process to understand root causes
• Communication strategy for different stakeholders (users, employees, regulators, public)
• Remediation steps to address the underlying ethical issues
• Preventative measures to avoid similar incidents in the future
• Create a timeline for implementation of your plan
• Prepare a 15-minute presentation of your response strategy

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide feedback on the comprehensiveness and practicality of the response plan
• Highlight one particularly effective element of their approach
• Suggest one additional consideration they might have overlooked
• Ask the candidate to spend 10 minutes revising their communication strategy based on the feedback

Frequently Asked Questions

How long should we allocate for these work sample exercises?

Each exercise requires approximately 1-2 hours of total time, including preparation, execution, and feedback. We recommend scheduling them as separate sessions rather than attempting to complete multiple exercises in a single interview. This allows candidates sufficient time to demonstrate their capabilities without fatigue.

Should we use real company projects for these exercises?

While using real projects provides authentic context, we recommend creating hypothetical scenarios based on real challenges your organization has faced. This protects sensitive information while still testing relevant skills. Ensure the scenarios are realistic enough to meaningfully assess candidates' capabilities.

What if we don't have team members who can effectively role-play the stakeholders?

The cross-functional collaboration exercise is most effective with multiple stakeholders, but can be modified if necessary. Consider involving actual stakeholders from different departments who regularly interact with your AI ethics function. Alternatively, provide written stakeholder perspectives and have candidates explain how they would address each one.

How should we evaluate candidates across these different exercises?

Create a structured scorecard for each exercise that aligns with the key competencies for the role: analytical thinking, ethical judgment, communication skills, collaborative mindset, and adaptability. Rate candidates on specific observable behaviors rather than general impressions, and compare their performance against consistent criteria.

Should candidates have access to resources during these exercises?

Yes, allowing candidates to reference ethical frameworks, regulations, or other resources during the exercises more accurately simulates real-world conditions. This approach tests their ability to apply knowledge rather than simply recall it, which is more relevant to on-the-job performance.

How can we ensure these exercises don't disadvantage candidates from underrepresented groups?

Review all exercise materials for potential bias in language or scenarios. Provide clear instructions and equal preparation time to all candidates. Consider having diverse evaluators assess the responses, and use structured evaluation criteria to minimize subjective judgments.

In today's AI landscape, organizations need ethics consultants who can translate abstract ethical principles into practical guidelines and actions. These work sample exercises will help you identify candidates who not only understand ethical theory but can effectively implement ethical practices in real-world business contexts.

For additional support in designing a comprehensive hiring process for AI Ethics Consultants, explore Yardstick's suite of tools including our AI Job Description Generator, AI Interview Question Generator, and AI Interview Guide Generator. You can also find more information about the AI Ethics Consultant role in our detailed job description.

Build a complete interview guide for this role by signing up for a free Yardstick account here