Effective Work Sample Exercises for Finance Manager Interviews

The Finance Manager role is pivotal to an organization's success, serving as the bridge between day-to-day financial operations and strategic decision-making. When hiring for this critical position, traditional interviews alone often fail to reveal a candidate's true capabilities in handling complex financial scenarios, leading teams, and driving process improvements.

Work samples provide a window into how candidates actually perform tasks central to the Finance Manager role. By observing candidates analyze financial data, communicate complex information, lead teams, and solve problems in real-time, hiring managers can make more informed decisions based on demonstrated skills rather than self-reported experience.

The cost of a poor hire in a Finance Manager position can be substantial—from financial mismanagement to compliance issues and team dysfunction. Implementing structured work samples significantly reduces this risk by revealing how candidates approach the actual challenges they'll face on the job.

These exercises are designed to evaluate the essential competencies identified in the job description: analytical thinking, leadership, communication, adaptability, and integrity. Each activity simulates real-world scenarios Finance Managers encounter, providing concrete evidence of a candidate's capabilities beyond what appears on their resume.

By incorporating these four carefully crafted work samples into your interview process, you'll gain deeper insights into each candidate's financial acumen, leadership potential, and strategic thinking—ultimately leading to better hiring decisions for this crucial role.

Activity #1: Financial Analysis and Variance Reporting

This exercise evaluates a candidate's analytical thinking and communication skills by asking them to review financial statements, identify variances, and present their findings. Finance Managers must regularly analyze financial data and communicate insights to both finance and non-finance stakeholders, making this a core competency for the role.

Directions for the Company:

• Prepare a simplified set of financial statements (income statement, balance sheet) with deliberate variances or issues embedded within them.
• Include month-over-month or year-over-year comparisons with some significant variances.
• Provide relevant industry benchmarks or company targets for context.
• Allow 45-60 minutes for the candidate to review the materials and prepare their analysis.
• Have a small panel (2-3 people) available to receive the candidate's presentation, including at least one non-finance executive.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the provided financial statements and identify key variances or issues that require attention.
• Prepare a brief (10-minute) presentation explaining your findings and recommendations.
• Focus on communicating financial insights in a way that both finance and non-finance stakeholders can understand.
• Be prepared to answer questions about your analysis and recommendations.
• Prioritize the issues you've identified based on potential impact to the business.

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the presentation, provide specific feedback on one aspect the candidate did well (e.g., "Your explanation of the gross margin variance was particularly clear and actionable").
• Offer one area for improvement (e.g., "I'd like to see more specific recommendations on addressing the cash flow issue you identified").
• Ask the candidate to take 5 minutes to revise their recommendation for the improvement area, observing how they incorporate feedback.

Activity #2: Team Leadership Scenario Role Play

This role play assesses the candidate's leadership and communication skills in managing a finance team. The scenario tests how they handle performance issues, provide feedback, and develop team members—essential responsibilities for a Finance Manager who will be leading accounting professionals.

Directions for the Company:

• Prepare a scenario involving a team member who is technically proficient but struggling with meeting deadlines and communicating effectively with other departments.
• Provide background information on the "team member" including their role, experience level, and specific performance issues.
• Assign someone to play the role of the team member, with clear guidance on how to respond to different approaches.
• Allow the candidate 15 minutes to review the materials and prepare for the conversation.
• Limit the role play to 20 minutes.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the information about your team member's performance issues.
• Prepare for and conduct a coaching conversation addressing the performance concerns.
• Your goals are to:
• Clearly communicate performance expectations
• Understand any barriers or challenges the team member is facing
• Develop a concrete plan for improvement
• Maintain a positive working relationship
• Be prepared to handle potential resistance or defensiveness.

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the role play, provide feedback on what the candidate did effectively in the conversation (e.g., "You did an excellent job of asking open-ended questions to understand the root causes").
• Offer one specific suggestion for improvement (e.g., "You could have been more explicit about the consequences of continued performance issues").
• Give the candidate 5 minutes to reflect, then ask them to briefly demonstrate how they would incorporate this feedback if they could redo part of the conversation.

Activity #3: Process Improvement Case Study

This exercise evaluates the candidate's ability to identify inefficiencies and implement process improvements—a key responsibility highlighted in the job description. It tests analytical thinking, adaptability, and the ability to balance tactical operations with strategic planning.

Directions for the Company:

• Create a case study describing a finance department with inefficient month-end close processes, taking 10-12 days to complete.
• Include a flowchart of the current process with clear bottlenecks and inefficiencies.
• Provide relevant constraints (e.g., limited resources, compliance requirements, legacy systems).
• Allow 45-60 minutes for the candidate to review the materials and develop recommendations.
• Have 1-2 interviewers available to discuss the candidate's approach.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the current month-end close process and identify key inefficiencies or bottlenecks.
• Develop a plan to reduce the close timeline by at least 3-5 days while maintaining accuracy and compliance.
• Consider both quick wins and longer-term improvements.
• Prepare to discuss:
• Specific changes you would implement
• How you would prioritize these changes
• How you would measure success
• How you would manage the change process with the team
• Document your recommendations in a simple format that could be presented to senior leadership.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide positive feedback on one aspect of the candidate's approach (e.g., "Your phased implementation plan was particularly thoughtful and realistic").
• Offer one area for improvement (e.g., "Your plan didn't address how to maintain team morale during the change process").
• Ask the candidate to take 5 minutes to revise or expand their approach based on this feedback.

Activity #4: Budget Planning and Stakeholder Communication

This exercise tests the candidate's financial planning abilities and communication skills—particularly their ability to translate complex financial concepts for non-finance audiences. It also evaluates how they handle competing priorities and navigate cross-departmental collaboration.

Directions for the Company:

• Create a scenario where the finance team needs to work with department heads to reduce their budget requests by 10-15% for the coming year.
• Provide:
• Current year's budget by department
• Initial budget requests for next year (exceeding available resources)
• Company priorities and strategic initiatives
• Brief profiles of the department heads and their communication styles
• Assign 1-2 interviewers to role play as department heads (e.g., Sales, Marketing, or Operations).
• Allow 30 minutes for preparation and 20 minutes for the role play.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the budget information and prepare for a conversation with department heads about reducing their budget requests.
• Develop a framework for evaluating which expenses to prioritize based on company strategy.
• Prepare to:
• Explain the budget constraints clearly
• Ask effective questions to understand department priorities
• Suggest potential areas for reduction
• Handle potential pushback or resistance
• Reach a collaborative solution
• Your goal is to achieve the necessary budget reductions while maintaining positive working relationships.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide specific positive feedback on the candidate's approach (e.g., "You did an excellent job of acknowledging the department's priorities before suggesting cuts").
• Offer one area for improvement (e.g., "You could have provided more context about how the budget constraints align with company strategy").
• Ask the candidate to take 5 minutes to reflect, then demonstrate how they would incorporate this feedback in a follow-up conversation.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long should we allocate for these work samples in our interview process?

Each exercise requires approximately 60-90 minutes total, including preparation, execution, and feedback. We recommend selecting 1-2 exercises most relevant to your specific needs rather than attempting all four in a single interview day. Consider spreading them across different interview stages or combining complementary exercises.

Should we use the same exercises for all Finance Manager candidates?

Yes, using consistent exercises allows for more objective comparison between candidates. However, you may need to adjust the complexity based on the seniority of the role or tailor industry-specific details to make the scenarios more relevant to your organization.

What if our company doesn't have the resources to create these materials?

Start simple. Even basic financial statements with intentional variances or a straightforward process improvement case can provide valuable insights. Focus on creating one high-quality exercise rather than attempting all four with insufficient resources.

How should we evaluate candidates' performance on these exercises?

Create a structured scorecard aligned with the key competencies from your job description. Rate candidates on specific observable behaviors rather than general impressions. Have multiple interviewers evaluate the same exercise when possible to reduce individual bias.

What if a candidate has a different approach than what we expected?

This is valuable information! The goal isn't to test whether candidates arrive at a predetermined "right answer," but rather to observe their thought process, problem-solving approach, and communication style. Different approaches may reveal innovative thinking or highlight blind spots in your current processes.

How do we ensure these exercises don't disadvantage candidates from different backgrounds?

Provide clear instructions and adequate preparation time. Ensure the scenarios don't require company-specific knowledge that only internal candidates would have. Focus evaluation on the skills and competencies required for the role rather than familiarity with specific tools or terminology.

Finding the right Finance Manager is crucial for your organization's financial health and strategic growth. By incorporating these practical work samples into your interview process, you'll gain deeper insights into candidates' actual capabilities and fit for your specific needs.

Ready to take your hiring process to the next level? Yardstick offers AI-powered tools to help you create customized job descriptions, interview questions, and comprehensive interview guides tailored to your organization's unique requirements. Learn more about our Finance Manager resources at https://yardstick.team/job-description/finance-manager.

Build a complete interview guide for this role by signing up for a free Yardstick account here