In the context of HR management, influencing others is the ability to persuade, convince, and gain buy-in from stakeholders at all levels without relying solely on formal authority. This competency is essential for HR Managers who must drive organizational change, implement policies, and champion people initiatives across diverse departments and leadership levels.

Influencing others in HR roles encompasses several dimensions: strategic persuasion, relationship building, negotiation skills, stakeholder management, and effective communication. HR Managers must master the art of framing messages to resonate with different audiences while maintaining authenticity and building trust. They need to navigate complex organizational dynamics, manage resistance to change, and find common ground among competing interests.

For HR Managers specifically, this skill is crucial because they often serve as the bridge between executive leadership and employees, requiring them to influence upward, laterally, and downward simultaneously. Whether implementing a new performance management system, advocating for diversity initiatives, or negotiating benefits packages, HR Managers who can effectively influence others achieve greater results with less friction and more sustainable buy-in. The most successful HR leaders know how to gain commitment rather than just compliance by connecting initiatives to stakeholders' values and priorities.

When evaluating candidates for this competency, focus on listening for specific techniques they've used to influence others in challenging situations. Pay attention to how they've adapted their approach based on their audience, how they've overcome resistance, and what lessons they've learned from both successes and failures. The most promising candidates will demonstrate self-awareness about their influencing style and show versatility in their approaches to different stakeholder groups.

Interview Questions

Tell me about a time when you needed to implement a significant HR policy or program that faced resistance from department managers. How did you influence them to support the initiative?

Areas to Cover:

• The specific policy or program and why it faced resistance
• How they identified stakeholder concerns and priorities
• Strategies used to build buy-in and overcome objections
• How they tailored their approach to different managers
• The outcome of their influence efforts
• Lessons learned about influencing in similar situations

Follow-Up Questions:

• What did you learn about the specific concerns of the resistant managers, and how did that inform your approach?
• How did you adjust your communication strategy for different audiences?
• If you faced this situation again, what would you do differently?
• How did you measure the success of your influence approach?

Describe a situation where you had to persuade senior leadership to invest in an HR initiative that wasn't initially a priority for them.

Areas to Cover:

• The HR initiative and its importance
• The challenges in gaining executive attention and support
• Data or evidence they gathered to strengthen their case
• How they aligned the initiative with business priorities
• The specific techniques used to influence decision-makers
• The outcome and impact of the initiative

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you prepare for your interactions with senior leadership?
• What objections did you encounter and how did you address them?
• How did you demonstrate the business value of your proposal?
• What was most effective in changing their perspective?

Tell me about a time when you had to influence a change in employee behavior or culture without having direct authority over those employees.

Areas to Cover:

• The behavior or cultural change needed and why
• Their approach to gaining informal influence
• How they identified and engaged key influencers within the organization
• Communication strategies they employed
• How they measured progress
• Challenges faced and how they overcame them

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you identify the key influencers in the organization?
• What resistance did you encounter and how did you address it?
• How did you maintain momentum for the change over time?
• What would you do differently in a similar situation in the future?

Share an experience where you needed to negotiate a compromise between competing departmental needs in an HR-related matter.

Areas to Cover:

• The competing needs or perspectives at stake
• Their process for understanding each department's priorities
• Techniques used to find common ground
• How they built trust with the different parties
• The solution reached and how it balanced competing interests
• How they communicated throughout the process

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you prepare for the negotiation process?
• What techniques did you use to help the parties see each other's perspectives?
• What was the most challenging aspect of this situation, and how did you handle it?
• How did you ensure the compromise was implemented successfully?

Give me an example of a time when you had to influence a decision where data and analytics were important to your argument.

Areas to Cover:

• The decision that needed to be influenced
• The data they gathered and how they analyzed it
• How they presented complex information to make it compelling
• Any resistance they encountered to the data-driven approach
• How they balanced data with other persuasive elements
• The outcome of their influence attempt

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you determine which data points would be most persuasive?
• How did you present the data to make it accessible and compelling?
• Were there stakeholders who weren't convinced by the data? How did you address their concerns?
• How has this experience shaped how you use data in influence situations?

Describe a situation where you had to gain buy-in for a controversial HR decision or policy change.

Areas to Cover:

• The controversial decision or policy and why it was contentious
• Their assessment of different stakeholders' positions
• The influence strategy they developed
• How they addressed emotional reactions and resistance
• Communication approaches used before, during, and after implementation
• The results and any modifications made based on feedback

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you anticipate potential objections to this change?
• What was the most effective approach you used to gain support?
• How did you handle those who remained strongly opposed?
• What did this experience teach you about managing controversial changes?

Tell me about a time when you had to influence cross-functional teams to adopt a new HR process or system.

Areas to Cover:

• The new process or system and the rationale for implementation
• The different teams involved and their specific concerns
• Their approach to understanding each team's workflow and needs
• Strategies used to demonstrate the value proposition for each team
• How they built coalitions and champions across functions
• The outcome and any adjustments made to gain adoption

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you tailor your messaging to different functional areas?
• What resistance did you encounter and how did you overcome it?
• How did you train and support teams through the transition?
• What would you do differently if you faced a similar situation?

Share an experience where you successfully influenced company leadership to invest in employee development or wellbeing initiatives.

Areas to Cover:

• The specific initiative and why it was important
• How they built the business case for the investment
• Their approach to understanding leadership priorities and concerns
• Techniques used to make the initiative compelling to decision-makers
• How they demonstrated potential ROI or business impact
• The outcome and any evidence of success

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you connect the initiative to business outcomes that leadership cared about?
• What objections did you face and how did you address them?
• How did you follow up to demonstrate the value of the investment?
• What have you learned about influencing leadership on people-centered investments?

Describe a time when you had to influence without authority in a matrix organization or project team.

Areas to Cover:

• The context of the matrix or project environment
• The influence challenge they faced without direct authority
• Relationship-building approaches they employed
• How they created mutual value and aligned interests
• Specific influence techniques that worked well
• Challenges encountered and how they addressed them

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you establish credibility with those you needed to influence?
• What was most challenging about influencing without authority?
• How did you handle any resistance or competing priorities?
• What have you learned about effective influence in matrix environments?

Tell me about a time when your initial attempts to influence a key stakeholder were unsuccessful. How did you adapt your approach?

Areas to Cover:

• The initial influence situation and approach
• Why they believe their first attempt was unsuccessful
• How they reassessed the situation and stakeholder needs
• Changes they made to their influence strategy
• The outcome of their revised approach
• Key lessons learned about adaptability in influence

Follow-Up Questions:

• What signals told you that your initial approach wasn't working?
• How did you gain new insights into the stakeholder's perspective?
• What specific changes to your approach made the biggest difference?
• How has this experience shaped your approach to influence in other situations?

Give me an example of when you needed to influence a change in perspective among HR team members who were resistant to a new approach or methodology.

Areas to Cover:

• The change in perspective needed and why
• Sources of resistance among the HR team
• How they diagnosed the underlying concerns
• Approaches used to address resistance
• How they modeled the desired perspective
• The outcome and any ongoing challenges

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you recognize and acknowledge valid concerns from your team?
• What techniques did you find most effective in shifting perspectives?
• How did you balance pushing for change with maintaining team morale?
• What did you learn about influencing your own team members?

Describe your approach to influencing organizational leaders during a time of significant change or uncertainty.

Areas to Cover:

• The change context and the specific influence needed
• How they assessed the leaders' concerns and priorities during uncertainty
• Their approach to building trust and credibility
• Communication strategies employed
• How they provided stability while advocating for necessary changes
• Results of their influence efforts

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you adapt your influence style to the uncertain environment?
• What was most challenging about influencing during this period?
• How did you maintain your own credibility when factors were shifting?
• What did you learn about influence during times of change?

Tell me about a situation where you had to influence how employee data or analytics were used in decision-making.

Areas to Cover:

• The specific data/analytics situation and the decision context
• Stakeholders involved and their perspectives on data use
• How they educated stakeholders about appropriate data interpretation
• Ethical considerations they addressed
• How they balanced data-driven and human-centered approaches
• The outcome and influence on future data use

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you help non-HR stakeholders understand the implications of the data?
• What concerns or resistance did you encounter about how data should be used?
• How did you ensure ethical considerations were part of the conversation?
• What impact did this have on future approaches to people data in the organization?

Share an experience where you had to influence employees to embrace a significant cultural change as part of an organizational transformation.

Areas to Cover:

• The cultural change needed and its connection to organizational goals
• Their assessment of the cultural landscape and resistance points
• How they identified and engaged formal and informal influencers
• Communication and change management approaches used
• How they measured progress and adapted their approach
• The results achieved and lessons learned

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you identify the key levers for cultural change in the organization?
• What resistance did you encounter and how did you address it?
• How did you help employees see the personal benefits of the cultural shift?
• What would you do differently in leading cultural change in the future?

Describe a time when you had to convince skeptical managers to adopt a new talent management approach or HR technology.

Areas to Cover:

• The new approach or technology and its intended benefits
• Sources of manager skepticism or resistance
• How they demonstrated value to these managers
• Pilot programs or proof of concept approaches used
• Training and support provided to facilitate adoption
• The outcome and level of adoption achieved

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you identify and address the specific concerns of the skeptical managers?
• What evidence or examples were most convincing to them?
• How did you balance pushing for adoption with respecting their concerns?
• What have you learned about introducing new HR approaches to resistant audiences?

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes influencing others particularly important for HR Manager roles compared to other management positions?

HR Managers occupy a unique position where they must drive people-centered initiatives that affect the entire organization while often lacking direct authority over most stakeholders. They need to influence upward to executives who control budgets and strategy, laterally across department leaders who may have competing priorities, and downward to employees whose buy-in is essential for successful implementation. This multi-directional influence requirement, combined with the often sensitive nature of HR matters, makes influencing skills particularly crucial for HR leadership roles.

How can I tell if a candidate is truly skilled at influence versus just being charismatic?

Look beyond charm and articulate communication to evaluate whether the candidate can describe specific influence techniques they've used in different situations. Strong candidates will discuss how they've adapted their approach based on audience analysis, how they've built coalitions, used data effectively, handled resistance, and can point to concrete outcomes of their influence efforts. Ask about both successes and failures—truly skilled influencers can reflect on what didn't work and show how they've evolved their approach.

Should I be concerned if a candidate seems too focused on getting their way versus true influence?

Yes. Effective influence in HR roles isn't about manipulating others or "winning" at all costs. Listen for candidates who emphasize understanding others' perspectives, finding mutual benefit, and building sustainable buy-in rather than forcing compliance. The best HR influencers build trust and relationships that enable long-term effectiveness rather than short-term victories. If a candidate's examples focus solely on getting what they wanted without consideration for stakeholder needs or organizational context, this may indicate a transactional rather than transformational approach to influence.

How many behavioral questions about influence should I include in my interview?

For an HR Manager role, where influence is a critical competency, include 3-4 well-crafted behavioral questions that probe different dimensions of influence (e.g., upward influence with executives, peer influence across departments, and influence during resistance or change). Quality is more important than quantity—ask fewer questions but probe deeply with thoughtful follow-ups to understand the candidate's approach, reasoning, and adaptability.

How can I adapt these questions for a more junior HR role?

For junior HR roles, modify these questions to focus on smaller-scale influence scenarios that would be relevant to their experience level. For example, instead of asking about influencing organizational culture change, ask about influencing a small team or successfully advocating for an improvement to a process. Focus more on foundational influence skills like clear communication, understanding others' perspectives, and building credibility. Look for potential and learning orientation rather than extensive experience with complex influence situations.

Interested in a full interview guide with Influencing Others for HR Manager Roles as a key trait? Sign up for Yardstick and build it for free.