Behavioral interviewing is a structured interview method focused on gathering specific examples of past behaviors as predictors of future performance. Unlike traditional interviews that rely on hypothetical situations or general discussions of skills, behavioral interviews probe for concrete evidence of how candidates have actually handled challenges, opportunities, and responsibilities in the past. This evidence-based approach is rooted in the principle that past behavior is the most reliable indicator of future performance.

Mastering behavioral interviewing techniques is essential for hiring teams seeking to make more objective, data-driven hiring decisions. When implemented properly, this approach helps interviewers move beyond rehearsed answers to gain deeper insights into a candidate's actual capabilities, work style, and cultural fit. Behavioral interviews can reveal critical competencies such as problem-solving abilities, leadership potential, adaptability, communication skills, and teamwork effectiveness. By focusing on specific examples from a candidate's history rather than hypothetical scenarios, interviewers can better assess whether candidates truly possess the skills and traits needed for success in a role.

To conduct effective behavioral interviews, interviewers must prepare thoughtful questions targeted to specific competencies, listen actively, and ask probing follow-up questions to gather complete information. Rather than asking "how would you handle X situation," behavioral questions ask "tell me about a time when you handled X situation." This subtle but powerful shift forces candidates to provide real evidence rather than theoretical responses, giving you much more valuable data for your hiring decisions. Let's explore some effective behavioral interview questions and techniques to help you improve your hiring process and make better talent decisions.

Interview Questions

Tell me about a time when you had to design and implement a new interview process that significantly improved hiring outcomes for your organization.

Areas to Cover:

• The specific challenges with the previous interview process
• How they identified what needed to change
• The research or best practices they consulted
• The specific changes they implemented
• How they gained buy-in from stakeholders
• Metrics used to measure improvement
• The actual results achieved

Follow-Up Questions:

• What resistance did you encounter and how did you overcome it?
• How did you ensure the new process was consistently applied across different hiring teams?
• What specific aspects of the new process had the biggest impact on improving hiring outcomes?
• What would you do differently if you were to implement this process again?

Describe a situation where you noticed inconsistencies in how candidates were being evaluated across your organization. How did you address this issue?

Areas to Cover:

• How they identified the inconsistency issue
• The specific challenges it was causing for the organization
• The approach they took to analyze the problem
• The solution they developed and implemented
• How they communicated changes to stakeholders
• The challenges they faced during implementation
• The results of their intervention

Follow-Up Questions:

• What data or observations first alerted you to this inconsistency?
• How did you get buy-in from interviewers who may have been resistant to changing their approach?
• What tools or frameworks did you implement to create more consistency?
• How did you measure whether your solution was effective?

Give me an example of when you had to train someone on behavioral interviewing techniques who was resistant to this approach. How did you handle it?

Areas to Cover:

• The specific resistance or objections they encountered
• Their approach to understanding the person's concerns
• The strategies they used to educate and convince the person
• How they demonstrated the value of behavioral interviewing
• The specific training methods they employed
• How they followed up to ensure adoption
• The outcome of their efforts

Follow-Up Questions:

• What specific concerns did this person have about behavioral interviewing?
• How did you customize your approach to address their specific objections?
• What evidence or examples did you use to demonstrate the effectiveness of behavioral interviewing?
• How did you know whether your training was successful?

Tell me about a time when you used behavioral interviewing techniques to uncover important information about a candidate that might have been missed using traditional interview methods.

Areas to Cover:

• The specific role they were hiring for
• The behavioral questions they asked
• How they followed up on the candidate's responses
• What significant insights they gained
• How this information influenced the hiring decision
• The eventual outcome with this candidate (if hired)
• How this experience shaped their future interviewing approach

Follow-Up Questions:

• What specific behavioral questions yielded the most valuable insights?
• How did you recognize that you needed to probe deeper into the candidate's response?
• How did you validate the information you uncovered through behavioral questioning?
• How did this experience change your approach to interviewing?

Describe a situation where you helped an organization move from an unstructured interview process to a structured behavioral interview process. What steps did you take?

Areas to Cover:

• The initial state of the interview process
• Their assessment of what needed to change
• The specific components of the structured process they implemented
• How they introduced behavioral interviewing techniques
• The training approach they used
• How they measured success
• The challenges they faced and how they overcame them

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you secure leadership support for making this change?
• What specific tools or frameworks did you implement to structure the interviews?
• How did you ensure interviewers were asking effective behavioral questions?
• What feedback did you receive after implementing the new process?

Tell me about a time when you helped create a standardized scoring system to evaluate candidates based on behavioral interview responses.

Areas to Cover:

• The specific need they identified for creating the scoring system
• The approach they took to developing the system
• How they determined which competencies to evaluate
• The specific criteria they established for scoring
• How they trained interviewers to use the system consistently
• The challenges they encountered in implementation
• The impact on hiring decisions and outcomes

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you ensure the scoring criteria were objective and fair?
• What calibration methods did you use to ensure consistent application across interviewers?
• How did you handle disagreements in scoring between different interviewers?
• What improvements in hiring outcomes did you observe after implementing this system?

Give me an example of when you had to analyze interview data to identify patterns or biases in how candidates were being evaluated.

Areas to Cover:

• The specific data they collected and analyzed
• The methodologies they used for analysis
• The patterns or biases they discovered
• How they presented their findings to stakeholders
• The recommendations they made based on their analysis
• The actions taken to address identified issues
• The outcomes of these interventions

Follow-Up Questions:

• What prompted you to look for patterns or biases in the interview data?
• What specific tools or methods did you use to analyze the data?
• How did different stakeholders respond to your findings?
• What changes were implemented as a result of your analysis, and how effective were they?

Describe a situation where you had to design behavioral interview questions for a role that you weren't personally familiar with.

Areas to Cover:

• Their approach to understanding the role requirements
• The resources they consulted for insight
• How they identified the key competencies to assess
• The process they used to develop relevant questions
• How they validated the effectiveness of the questions
• Adjustments they made based on feedback
• The effectiveness of the questions in practice

Follow-Up Questions:

• Who did you consult with to better understand the role?
• How did you ensure the questions would elicit valuable information about the key competencies?
• What techniques did you use to test or validate the questions before using them in actual interviews?
• How did you know whether the questions were effective?

Tell me about a time when you coached hiring managers on how to conduct effective behavioral interviews.

Areas to Cover:

• The specific challenges the hiring managers were facing
• Their approach to designing the coaching program
• The key behavioral interviewing techniques they taught
• Their methods for demonstrating these techniques
• How they provided feedback and reinforcement
• Challenges they encountered during the coaching process
• How they measured the effectiveness of their coaching

Follow-Up Questions:

• What were the most common misconceptions or challenges the hiring managers had about behavioral interviewing?
• How did you customize your coaching approach for different managers?
• What practice or role-playing exercises did you use to help managers develop their skills?
• What improvements did you observe in the managers' interviewing techniques after your coaching?

Give me an example of when you had to modify your behavioral interviewing approach for a candidate with limited work experience.

Areas to Cover:

• The specific situation and role they were interviewing for
• How they adapted their questioning approach
• Alternative sources of behavioral examples they explored
• How they helped the candidate understand what was being asked
• The effectiveness of their adapted approach
• What they learned from this experience
• How this influenced their future interviewing of less experienced candidates

Follow-Up Questions:

• What signals indicated you needed to modify your approach?
• What types of alternative experiences did you ask about to elicit relevant behavioral examples?
• How did you ensure fairness in comparison with candidates who had more traditional work experience?
• What specific questions yielded the most valuable insights from this candidate?

Describe a time when you identified that a candidate was giving generic or hypothetical answers rather than specific behavioral examples. How did you handle it?

Areas to Cover:

• The specific situation and questions being asked
• The indicators that the candidate was not providing specific examples
• Their technique for redirecting the candidate
• The approach they used to help the candidate understand what was being asked
• The specific follow-up questions they used
• The candidate's response to this redirection
• The outcome of this intervention

Follow-Up Questions:

• What specific phrases or patterns alerted you that the candidate was not providing behavioral examples?
• What techniques did you use to guide the candidate toward providing specific examples?
• How did you maintain rapport while redirecting the conversation?
• What did you learn about the candidate through this process?

Tell me about a time when you had to evaluate a candidate's behavioral responses in a role where technical skills were highly valued by the hiring team.

Areas to Cover:

• The specific role and technical requirements
• The behavioral competencies they identified as important
• How they balanced technical and behavioral assessment
• The specific behavioral questions they asked
• How they presented the behavioral assessment to technical stakeholders
• Any resistance they encountered and how they addressed it
• The impact of their behavioral assessment on the hiring decision

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you determine which behavioral competencies were most important for success in this technical role?
• How did you convince technically-focused stakeholders of the importance of behavioral assessment?
• What specific behavioral questions yielded the most valuable insights for this technical role?
• How did the behavioral assessment complement the technical evaluation?

Give me an example of when you had to train a panel of interviewers to conduct a coordinated behavioral interview process.

Areas to Cover:

• The specific hiring situation and interview panel composition
• Their approach to organizing the panel
• How they assigned specific competencies to different interviewers
• The training they provided on behavioral interviewing techniques
• How they ensured consistency across interviewers
• The method they used for sharing and integrating findings
• The effectiveness of the panel approach

Follow-Up Questions:

• How did you decide which competencies each interviewer should focus on?
• What guidance did you provide about sharing information between interviewers?
• How did you structure the post-interview debrief to ensure comprehensive evaluation?
• What challenges did you encounter with the panel approach, and how did you address them?

Describe a situation where you had to design behavioral interview questions to assess a candidate's potential rather than their experience.

Areas to Cover:

• The specific role and context for the hire
• How they defined "potential" for this specific role
• The competencies they identified as indicators of potential
• The specific behavioral questions they developed
• How they evaluated responses without direct experience to reference
• The effectiveness of their approach
• What they learned about assessing potential through behavioral interviewing

Follow-Up Questions:

• What indicators of potential did you find most valuable to assess through behavioral questions?
• How did you validate that your questions were actually measuring potential?
• What challenges did you face in evaluating responses that didn't come from directly relevant experience?
• How did you ensure fairness when comparing candidates with different levels of experience?

Tell me about a time when you had to revise your behavioral interview questions because they weren't yielding the insights you needed.

Areas to Cover:

• The original questions and why they weren't effective
• How they identified the problem with the questions
• Their approach to analyzing what needed to change
• The specific revisions they made
• How they tested the effectiveness of the new questions
• The improvement in insights gained
• What they learned about designing effective behavioral questions

Follow-Up Questions:

• What specific issues did you notice with the original questions?
• How did you determine what changes were needed?
• What principles guided your revision of the questions?
• How did you know the revised questions were more effective?

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between behavioral interview questions and traditional interview questions?

Behavioral interview questions focus on specific past experiences and require candidates to provide detailed examples of how they've handled situations relevant to the role. Traditional questions often ask about hypothetical scenarios ("What would you do if…") or general skills and preferences. Behavioral questions are more effective at predicting future performance because they collect evidence of actual past behavior, which is the best indicator of how someone will perform in the future.

How many behavioral questions should I include in a typical interview?

Quality is more important than quantity. It's better to ask 3-4 well-crafted behavioral questions with thorough follow-up than to rush through 10 questions with superficial responses. Each behavioral question, when properly explored with follow-up questions, can take 10-15 minutes to fully discuss. Plan your interview time accordingly, allowing candidates sufficient time to think and provide detailed responses.

How can I tell if a candidate is giving me a genuine behavioral example or just a hypothetical answer?

Listen for specificity. Genuine behavioral examples include details about a particular situation, the specific actions taken, and concrete results. If a candidate uses phrases like "typically I would" or "usually I" instead of describing a specific instance, they're likely giving you a hypothetical answer. When this happens, gently redirect them by saying, "Can you tell me about a specific time when you faced this situation?" or "Could you share a particular example from your experience?"

Should I tell candidates in advance that I'll be using behavioral interviewing techniques?

Yes, it's helpful to set expectations. You can inform candidates about your interview approach when scheduling the interview or at the beginning of the conversation. This gives them time to recall relevant experiences and provides a more level playing field for candidates who might be less familiar with behavioral interviewing. Remember, preparation is a positive sign, not something to discourage.

How can I adapt behavioral interviewing for early-career candidates with limited professional experience?

For candidates with limited professional experience, encourage them to draw from educational, volunteer, extracurricular, or personal projects. Phrase your questions to allow for broader interpretation, such as "Tell me about a time when you faced a challenging situation in any context" rather than "Tell me about a workplace challenge." The core behavioral competencies—like problem-solving, teamwork, or adaptability—can be demonstrated in many different settings, not just professional ones.

Interested in a full interview guide with Behavioral Interviewing Technique as a key trait? Sign up for Yardstick and build it for free.