Effective Work Samples for Evaluating AI Marketing Performance Prediction Skills

The intersection of artificial intelligence and marketing represents one of the most powerful opportunities for modern businesses to gain competitive advantage. Professionals skilled in AI for Marketing Asset Performance Prediction possess a rare combination of technical expertise and marketing acumen that allows organizations to forecast campaign outcomes, optimize resource allocation, and drive superior ROI. Finding candidates with this specialized skill set requires more than traditional interviews – it demands practical evaluation of their abilities in realistic scenarios.

Traditional interviews often fail to reveal a candidate's true capabilities in applying AI to marketing challenges. While resumes may list impressive credentials and past projects, only through hands-on exercises can you truly assess whether a candidate can translate theoretical knowledge into practical solutions for your specific marketing needs. The right work samples will demonstrate not only technical proficiency but also business acumen and communication skills essential for bridging the gap between data science and marketing teams.

The exercises outlined below are designed to evaluate candidates across multiple dimensions: technical AI skills, marketing domain knowledge, problem-solving approach, and ability to communicate complex findings to stakeholders. By observing candidates work through these scenarios, hiring managers can gain valuable insights into how prospects think, how they approach ambiguity, and how effectively they can deliver actionable intelligence from marketing data.

Implementing these work samples as part of your hiring process will significantly improve your ability to identify candidates who can truly drive marketing performance through AI-powered prediction. Rather than relying on self-reported skills or hypothetical discussions, these exercises create a standardized framework for comparing candidates objectively while giving them an authentic preview of the challenges they'll face in the role. This approach leads to better hiring decisions and stronger alignment between candidate expectations and actual job responsibilities.

Activity #1: Marketing Campaign Performance Prediction Model

This exercise evaluates a candidate's ability to build a predictive model for marketing campaign performance using historical data. It tests their technical skills in data preprocessing, feature engineering, model selection, and evaluation – all within the specific context of marketing analytics. Candidates must demonstrate not only their AI expertise but also their understanding of marketing KPIs and what drives campaign success.

Directions for the Company:

• Prepare a sanitized dataset of historical marketing campaigns with features such as channel, creative type, audience segments, spend, timing, and performance metrics (CTR, conversion rate, ROI, etc.).
• Include some data quality issues that require cleaning (missing values, outliers, etc.) to test the candidate's data preparation skills.
• Provide access to a notebook environment (like Google Colab or Jupyter) with necessary libraries pre-installed.
• Allow 2-3 hours for completion, either as a take-home assignment or during an extended interview session.
• Designate a technical evaluator familiar with both AI and marketing to review the solution and provide feedback.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Analyze the provided marketing campaign dataset to identify patterns and relationships.
• Preprocess the data appropriately, explaining your decisions for handling missing values, outliers, and feature engineering.
• Develop a predictive model to forecast the performance of future marketing campaigns.
• Evaluate your model using appropriate metrics and explain why these metrics are relevant for marketing decision-making.
• Create a brief summary (1-2 pages) explaining your approach, findings, and recommendations for improving campaign performance based on your model.
• Be prepared to discuss how your model could be implemented in a production environment and what additional data might improve predictions.

Feedback Mechanism:

• The evaluator should provide specific feedback on one technical strength (e.g., "Your feature engineering approach effectively captured seasonal patterns in the data") and one area for improvement (e.g., "The model doesn't account for diminishing returns on ad spend").
• Give the candidate 15-20 minutes to refine their approach based on the improvement feedback, focusing specifically on addressing that aspect of their solution.
• Observe how receptive they are to feedback and how effectively they can adapt their approach.

Activity #2: Creative Asset Performance Prediction

This exercise focuses specifically on predicting the performance of different creative assets (images, videos, copy) across marketing channels. It tests the candidate's ability to apply AI techniques to the creative aspects of marketing, which often involves unstructured data and more complex feature extraction. This skill is crucial for optimizing creative development and allocation of design resources.

Directions for the Company:

• Compile a dataset of creative assets (or metadata about them) along with their historical performance metrics.
• Include information about the assets such as format, dimensions, colors, themes, messaging type, and performance metrics like engagement rate, conversion rate, etc.
• If possible, provide actual images or videos; otherwise, detailed descriptions and extracted features will suffice.
• Prepare a brief on the company's creative strategy and typical audience to provide context.
• Allow 2-3 hours for completion.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Analyze the relationship between creative elements and performance metrics across different channels and audience segments.
• Develop a model that can predict how new creative assets might perform based on their characteristics.
• Identify the most influential creative elements that drive performance for different marketing objectives.
• Create a one-page summary of actionable insights for the creative team, explaining what types of assets they should prioritize for upcoming campaigns.
• Suggest a framework for ongoing testing and refinement of creative assets based on AI predictions.
• Be prepared to explain how your approach balances creative intuition with data-driven decision making.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide feedback on the candidate's ability to extract meaningful patterns from creative data (strength) and an area where their analysis could be more nuanced or actionable (improvement).
• Ask the candidate to revise their recommendations to the creative team based on the feedback.
• Evaluate how well they can translate technical findings into practical guidance for non-technical creative professionals.

Activity #3: Marketing Budget Allocation Optimization

This exercise tests the candidate's ability to apply AI to solve one of marketing's most challenging problems: optimal budget allocation across channels and campaigns. It requires combining predictive modeling with optimization techniques while considering business constraints and objectives. This activity reveals how candidates think about marketing strategy and ROI maximization.

Directions for the Company:

• Prepare a dataset with historical performance across multiple marketing channels, including spend levels and resulting performance metrics.
• Include information about channel saturation effects, seasonal patterns, and cross-channel interactions if available.
• Define a hypothetical total budget and business objectives (e.g., maximize conversions, reach a specific audience, maintain brand presence across channels).
• Provide any business constraints that should be considered (minimum spend requirements, maximum channel capacities, etc.).
• Allow 2-3 hours for completion.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Analyze historical performance data to understand the relationship between spending and results across different channels.
• Develop a model that predicts performance at different spending levels for each channel, accounting for diminishing returns and seasonal effects.
• Create an optimization algorithm that allocates the given budget across channels to maximize overall marketing performance.
• Prepare a presentation (5-7 slides) explaining your recommended budget allocation, the expected results, and the methodology behind your recommendations.
• Include sensitivity analysis showing how the allocation might change under different scenarios or objectives.
• Be prepared to defend your recommendations and discuss implementation challenges.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide feedback on the candidate's strategic thinking and technical approach (strength) and an aspect of their solution that doesn't adequately address business realities or constraints (improvement).
• Ask the candidate to revise a specific part of their allocation strategy based on the feedback.
• Evaluate how well they balance mathematical optimization with practical marketing considerations.

Activity #4: AI Marketing Roadmap Development

This exercise evaluates the candidate's ability to plan and prioritize AI initiatives for marketing performance prediction. It tests their strategic thinking, project planning skills, and understanding of the AI implementation lifecycle in a marketing context. This activity reveals how candidates approach complex, long-term projects that require both technical expertise and business alignment.

Directions for the Company:

• Prepare a brief describing your current marketing analytics capabilities, available data sources, and business objectives.
• Include information about technical infrastructure, team composition, and any previous AI initiatives (successful or unsuccessful).
• Outline key marketing challenges that could potentially be addressed through AI.
• Provide a hypothetical budget and timeframe for implementing new AI capabilities.
• Allow 2-3 hours for completion, or assign as a take-home exercise.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Develop a 12-month roadmap for implementing AI-powered marketing performance prediction capabilities.
• Identify and prioritize specific use cases based on potential business impact, technical feasibility, and resource requirements.
• Outline the data requirements, model development approach, and implementation steps for each initiative.
• Address potential challenges and dependencies, including data quality issues, integration with existing systems, and team capabilities.
• Create a presentation (8-10 slides) outlining your proposed roadmap, including milestones, success metrics, and resource requirements.
• Be prepared to discuss how you would adapt the roadmap based on early results or changing business priorities.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide feedback on the candidate's strategic vision and practical implementation plan (strength) and an aspect of their roadmap that may be unrealistic or misaligned with business priorities (improvement).
• Ask the candidate to revise their prioritization or approach for a specific initiative based on the feedback.
• Evaluate how well they balance ambition with pragmatism and how effectively they sequence dependencies.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long should we allow candidates to complete these exercises?

For in-person exercises, allocate 2-3 hours for technical activities. For take-home assignments, set a clear timeframe (typically 3-5 days) but specify an expected effort of 3-4 hours. The roadmap exercise works particularly well as a take-home assignment, while the creative asset prediction could be conducted in-person to observe the candidate's thinking process.

Should we provide real company data for these exercises?

While using real data creates an authentic experience, it's best to use sanitized or synthetic data that resembles your actual marketing data without revealing sensitive information. This protects your business while still testing relevant skills. Ensure the data contains enough complexity to challenge candidates but isn't unnecessarily convoluted.

How technical should we expect the solutions to be?

The ideal candidate should demonstrate both technical proficiency and business acumen. Look for solutions that use appropriate AI techniques without unnecessary complexity. The focus should be on solving the marketing problem effectively, not showcasing the most advanced algorithms. The candidate should be able to explain their technical choices in business terms.

What if candidates don't have access to specific AI tools or platforms?

Provide access to necessary tools during the exercise or specify which common tools (Python, R, etc.) candidates should use. For take-home assignments, choose tools that are widely available or provide temporary access to your preferred platforms. The focus should be on the candidate's approach and thinking, not their familiarity with specific proprietary tools.

How do we evaluate candidates who take different approaches to the same problem?

Develop a rubric that evaluates fundamental skills rather than specific approaches. Consider factors like: appropriateness of the chosen technique for the problem, quality of data preprocessing, model evaluation methodology, clarity of insights, and business relevance of recommendations. Different approaches can be equally valid if they demonstrate sound reasoning and effective problem-solving.

Should we expect production-ready code from these exercises?

No, these exercises should evaluate problem-solving approach and conceptual understanding rather than production code quality. Look for clean, well-documented code that demonstrates clear thinking, but don't expect the level of robustness required for production systems. The candidate should, however, be able to discuss how their solution would need to be enhanced for production deployment.

AI for Marketing Asset Performance Prediction represents a specialized skill set that can dramatically transform marketing effectiveness. By implementing these work samples in your hiring process, you'll be able to identify candidates who can truly bridge the gap between advanced AI techniques and practical marketing applications. The right hire will not only understand the technical aspects of predictive modeling but also how to translate those insights into actionable marketing strategies that drive measurable business results.

For more resources to improve your hiring process, explore Yardstick's suite of AI-powered hiring tools, including our AI Job Descriptions, AI Interview Question Generator, and AI Interview Guide Generator.

Build a complete interview guide for AI Marketing Performance Prediction skills by signing up for a free Yardstick account