Effective Work Sample Exercises for Hiring Top Mechanical Engineers

Mechanical Engineers are the backbone of product development and innovation in many industries. They transform concepts into tangible products through their expertise in design, analysis, and problem-solving. However, identifying truly exceptional mechanical engineering talent goes beyond reviewing resumes and conducting standard interviews. The technical nature of this role demands a more hands-on evaluation approach.

Traditional interviews often fail to reveal a candidate's true capabilities in mechanical engineering. While a candidate might eloquently discuss their experience with CAD software or problem-solving methodologies, their actual proficiency becomes apparent only when faced with realistic challenges. Work samples provide this crucial insight by simulating the actual tasks and challenges the engineer will encounter on the job.

For mechanical engineers specifically, practical exercises reveal critical skills that might otherwise remain hidden: their approach to design constraints, attention to technical details, ability to communicate complex concepts to non-technical stakeholders, and how they balance theoretical knowledge with practical application. These skills directly impact their ability to deliver successful projects and integrate with your existing team.

The following work sample exercises are designed to evaluate the essential competencies of mechanical engineering candidates: technical design skills, analytical thinking, cross-functional collaboration, and attention to detail. By implementing these exercises in your hiring process, you'll gain deeper insights into each candidate's capabilities and make more informed hiring decisions that lead to successful, long-term placements.

Activity #1: CAD Design Challenge

This exercise evaluates a candidate's proficiency with CAD software, their design thinking process, and their ability to work within constraints. CAD skills are fundamental for mechanical engineers, as they'll use these tools daily to create and modify designs. This exercise also reveals how candidates approach design problems, balance competing requirements, and apply engineering principles to create practical solutions.

Directions for the Company:

• Prepare a design brief for a simple mechanical component or assembly that can be completed in 60-90 minutes. The component should have specific functional requirements, material constraints, and dimensional limitations.
• Provide access to the CAD software your company typically uses (e.g., SolidWorks, AutoCAD, Fusion 360). If remote, ensure candidates have access to compatible software or provide a temporary license.
• Create a rubric for evaluation that includes technical accuracy, design creativity, adherence to requirements, and efficiency of the design.
• Send the design brief to candidates 24 hours before the interview to allow for familiarization with the requirements.
• Include any relevant company standards or design guidelines that should be followed.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the design brief and requirements thoroughly before beginning the exercise.
• Using the provided CAD software, design the requested component or assembly within the specified constraints.
• Document your design decisions, assumptions, and any trade-offs you made during the process.
• Prepare a brief (5-minute) explanation of your design approach, highlighting key features and how they address the requirements.
• Be prepared to discuss how your design could be optimized for manufacturing or improved with additional time.

Feedback Mechanism:

• After the candidate presents their design, provide specific feedback on one aspect they executed well (e.g., "Your approach to the mounting interface was particularly elegant and manufacturable").
• Offer one constructive improvement suggestion (e.g., "The wall thickness varies significantly, which might create manufacturing challenges").
• Ask the candidate to spend 10-15 minutes modifying their design based on the feedback, focusing specifically on the improvement area identified.
• Observe how receptive they are to feedback and their ability to quickly iterate on their design.

Activity #2: Technical Problem-Solving Simulation

This exercise assesses a candidate's analytical thinking, troubleshooting methodology, and ability to develop practical solutions to engineering problems. Problem-solving is at the core of mechanical engineering, and this activity reveals how candidates approach complex issues, what resources they utilize, and how they balance theoretical knowledge with practical constraints.

Directions for the Company:

• Create a realistic technical problem scenario that mechanical engineers might encounter in your organization (e.g., a component failure analysis, a system performance issue, or an optimization challenge).
• Compile relevant data, specifications, and constraints that would be available in a real-world scenario.
• Prepare visual aids such as diagrams, performance graphs, or simplified CAD models to help illustrate the problem.
• Develop a set of guiding questions to help evaluate the candidate's thought process if they get stuck.
• Allocate 45-60 minutes for this exercise.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the technical problem scenario and all provided materials.
• Analyze the issue systematically, identifying potential root causes and factors contributing to the problem.
• Develop at least two potential solutions to address the identified issues.
• For each solution, outline the advantages, disadvantages, implementation considerations, and any additional data you would need to fully validate the approach.
• Prepare a brief explanation of your analysis and recommendations, including the rationale behind your preferred solution.
• Be prepared to answer questions about your approach and how you would implement your solution.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide positive feedback on one aspect of their problem-solving approach (e.g., "Your systematic elimination of potential causes was very thorough").
• Offer one constructive suggestion for improvement (e.g., "Consider how manufacturing constraints might affect your proposed solution").
• Ask the candidate to spend 10 minutes refining their recommended solution based on the feedback.
• Evaluate their ability to incorporate new considerations into their thinking and adapt their approach.

Activity #3: Cross-Functional Collaboration Role Play

This exercise evaluates a candidate's communication skills, particularly their ability to explain technical concepts to non-technical stakeholders and collaborate effectively with cross-functional teams. Mechanical engineers regularly interact with manufacturing, quality, project management, and other departments, making these soft skills crucial for success in the role.

Directions for the Company:

• Develop a scenario where the mechanical engineer needs to explain a technical design decision or modification to team members from different departments (e.g., manufacturing, quality, marketing).
• Create role cards for interviewers who will play the parts of these cross-functional team members, including their background, concerns, and questions they should ask.
• Prepare a technical design or modification that has implications for multiple departments (e.g., a design change that improves performance but impacts manufacturing complexity).
• Provide the candidate with technical specifications and background information on the design 30 minutes before the exercise.
• Allocate 20-30 minutes for the role play.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the technical design or modification and understand its features, benefits, and potential challenges.
• Prepare to explain the technical aspects to colleagues from different departments who may not have engineering backgrounds.
• During the role play, clearly communicate the design details, address concerns from different perspectives, and work collaboratively to find solutions that balance technical requirements with other departmental needs.
• Be prepared to adjust your communication style based on the technical background of each stakeholder.
• Focus on finding collaborative solutions rather than simply defending the engineering perspective.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Provide positive feedback on one aspect of their communication approach (e.g., "You effectively translated complex technical concepts into terms that were accessible to everyone").
• Offer one constructive suggestion for improvement (e.g., "Consider addressing the manufacturing concerns more directly by acknowledging the trade-offs").
• Give the candidate 10 minutes to re-approach a specific part of the discussion based on the feedback.
• Evaluate their adaptability in communication style and willingness to find collaborative solutions.

Activity #4: Technical Specification and Compliance Review

This exercise assesses a candidate's attention to detail, knowledge of industry standards, and ability to ensure designs meet all relevant requirements. Mechanical engineers must ensure their designs comply with various standards and specifications, making this skill essential for producing safe, reliable, and manufacturable products.

Directions for the Company:

• Prepare a technical drawing or specification document for a mechanical component or system that contains several deliberate errors or compliance issues.
• Include a mix of obvious and subtle issues related to dimensions, tolerances, material specifications, safety factors, or regulatory compliance.
• Provide relevant reference materials such as applicable industry standards, internal design guidelines, or regulatory requirements.
• Create a comprehensive answer key that identifies all issues and explains why they are problematic.
• Allocate 45-60 minutes for this exercise.

Directions for the Candidate:

• Review the provided technical drawing or specification document thoroughly.
• Identify any errors, inconsistencies, or compliance issues in the documentation.
• For each issue identified, explain why it's problematic and propose a specific correction.
• Consider aspects such as manufacturability, assembly, maintenance, safety, and regulatory compliance.
• Prioritize the issues based on their potential impact on product performance, safety, and manufacturability.
• Document your findings in a clear, organized manner that would be useful for a design review meeting.

Feedback Mechanism:

• Acknowledge one area where the candidate demonstrated strong attention to detail or technical knowledge (e.g., "You caught the subtle tolerance stack-up issue that many candidates miss").
• Provide one constructive suggestion for improvement (e.g., "Consider how the material specification might affect the thermal performance requirements").
• Ask the candidate to spend 10 minutes reviewing a specific section again with this new consideration in mind.
• Evaluate their ability to incorporate new perspectives into their analysis and their thoroughness in addressing all aspects of compliance.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long should we allocate for these work sample exercises?

Each exercise is designed to take 45-90 minutes, including time for feedback and iteration. For on-site interviews, you might select 2-3 exercises to conduct in a half-day session. For remote interviews, consider spreading the exercises across multiple shorter sessions to prevent candidate fatigue.

Should we use the same exercises for entry-level and senior mechanical engineering candidates?

While the exercise formats can remain the same, adjust the complexity and expectations based on experience level. For entry-level candidates, focus more on fundamental skills and potential, while for senior candidates, increase the complexity and evaluate their strategic thinking and leadership capabilities within the exercises.

How can we conduct these exercises remotely?

For remote assessments, ensure candidates have access to necessary software (provide temporary licenses if needed), use video conferencing with screen sharing capabilities, and consider sending materials in advance. For the CAD exercise specifically, you might need to be flexible about software choices or provide access to browser-based CAD tools.

What if a candidate doesn't perform well in one exercise but excels in others?

Consider which exercises most closely align with the critical day-to-day responsibilities of your specific role. A candidate who struggles with the collaboration role play but excels in technical design might be perfect for a research-focused position but less suitable for a role requiring frequent client interaction. Use the complete picture from all exercises to make your decision.

Should we share these exercise details with candidates before the interview?

Provide general information about the types of exercises they'll complete and any preparation needed (such as software familiarity), but reserve specific details for the interview day. For exercises requiring preparation time, share those materials 24-48 hours in advance.

How do we ensure these exercises don't disadvantage candidates from diverse backgrounds?

Review your exercises to ensure they don't require specialized knowledge that would only be available to candidates from certain backgrounds. Focus on fundamental engineering principles rather than industry-specific knowledge that can be learned on the job. Consider having diverse reviewers evaluate your exercises for potential bias.

Finding the right mechanical engineer requires looking beyond credentials to evaluate practical skills and problem-solving abilities. These work sample exercises provide a comprehensive assessment of the technical and interpersonal skills needed for success in this role. By implementing these exercises, you'll gain deeper insights into each candidate's capabilities and make more informed hiring decisions.

Ready to elevate your entire hiring process? Yardstick offers AI-powered tools to streamline every aspect of candidate evaluation. Create customized job descriptions with our AI Job Description Generator, develop targeted interview questions with our AI Interview Question Generator, and build comprehensive interview guides with our AI Interview Guide Generator. For more insights on hiring mechanical engineers, check out our complete Mechanical Engineer job description.

Build a complete interview guide for this role by signing up for a free Yardstick account here